Analysis of Linguistically and Culturally Tailored Initiatives in Websites of Kidney Transplant Programs in the United States Between 2013-2018

Abstract

Introduction: Minority patients constitute the majority of the kidney transplant waiting list, yet they suffer greater difficulties in listing and longer wait times to transplantation. There is a lack of information regarding targeted efforts by transplant centers to improve transplant care for minority populations. Research Question: Our aim was to analyze all kidney transplant websites in the United States to identify changes over a 5-year period in the number of multilingual websites, reported culturally targeted initiatives, and center and provider diversity. Design: Surveys were developed to analyze center websites of all transplant programs in the United States. Those with incomplete information about their nephrology or surgical teams were excluded, resulting in 174 (73%) sites in 2013 and 185 (76%) in 2018. Results: Few websites were available in a language other than English, 6.3% in 2013 and 9.7% in 2018 (P = 0.24). Only 3 websites (1.3%) in 2013 and 7 (3.7%) in 2018 reported any evidence of a culturally targeted initiative (P = 0.23). In 2018, 35% of centers employed a Hispanic transplant physician, 77% had a transplant physician who spoke a language other than English, and 39% had a transplant physician who spoke Spanish. Discussion: Although minority patients are expected to grow in the United States, decreased access to transplantation continues to vex the transplant community. Very little progress has been made in the development of multilingual websites and culturally targeted initiatives.

Ethnic and Racial Diversity Among Surgeon and Non-Surgeon Deans of Allopathic Medical Schools

“…Although others have utilized similar methodology, there is room for errors. 4,6,7 To reduce bias and errors, two investigators verified all figures collected. We did not account for multiple racial backgrounds and non-binary genders.…”

“…Several publications have utilized this protocol to collect demographic information. 4,6,7 All data collected were verified by two team members to ensure accuracy.…”

Using Focus Groups to Understand Dialysis Staff Perspectives on Delivering Transplant Education

“…24 The need for culturally tailored materials for use with Black and Hispanic populations has also been addressed by researchers with culturally-sensitive online education, 11,25 but only 3.7% of transplant program websites in 2018 had any evidence of a culturally targeted initiative. 26 Efforts to improve provision of transplant-related information, particularly using online methods, are likely to have universal benefits.…”

Breaking Barriers and Bridging Gaps: Advancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Kidney Transplant Care for Black and Hispanic Patients in the United States

“…Interestingly, over 85% of all LDKTs are performed in just 10 United States transplant programs. Additionally, all of these centers had multilingual physicians, with approximately half of them being proficient in Spanish [ 37 ]. Providing culturally concordant care is not only sensible, but also effective, with multiple centers that have created platforms to help address disparities in the Hispanic population requiring renal transplant.…”