A general linear, donor controlled model of nutrient cycling in ecosystems has been previously developed. Stability analysis of this model was equated to analysis of the parameters of the second-order damped oscillation equation, and rankings among eight aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems were ascertained by those authors. In this paper, the results of direct experimental perturbations of the general model and the second-order approximation are presented. These digital and analog computer analyses show that the terms said by those authors to measure the resistance and resilience components of asymptotic stability do not reflect the actual response of either stability component for either model. Ecosystem resilience and resistance rankings, based upon the linear models, are reassigned according to observed temporal response.