Analysis of inter-rater agreement of latin american and modern dance sport

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study is to identify the consistency and correlation of referee evaluation according to the judging characteristics in the preliminary and semi-final of the Latin event of dance sports, thereby deriving the problem of referee reliability and suggesting alternatives for improvement. Methods The method of study is Based on the performance data of 54 amateur Latin dances match organized by the Korea Dance Sports Federation for a total of three years 11,850(preliminary rounds & semi-final). Based on the Kappa statistics and the degree of agreement(pa), the difference in the group of examination characteristics was derived and the correlation between the five Latin events was analyzed. Results As a result of through this study, the consistency of the dance sports referee and the characteristics of the judging in the event were confirmed, and the number of judges tended to be higher when the number of judges was seven, the more the number of subjects was, and the highest level of agreement was more than 70 percent of the judges. In addition, the higher the concordance of each of the five detailed items, the higher the correlation tendency. Conclusion Differences in visual aspects between dance sports judges and the difference in the judges' ratings due to the revision of the rules, the decrease in the number of competitors participating in the competition, the number of people to be eliminated in each round, and the proportion of judges with experience in the competition are different, and these differences affect the judges and show up in the scores. The Latin dance sports events based on objectivity and reliability to improve the correct standards of judges to find the same raters, work will be required and an assessment element. With a systematic way in and to carry out the review curriculum and educational development is considered necessary.

Analysis of the Interrater Reliability and Agreement of Breaking Battles in the 2018 Buenos Aires Youth Olympics

“…브레이킹 심사와 같이 다수 심판의 주관에 의해 심사를 진행하는 무용, 체육, 스포츠 분야 현장과 연구 분야에서 결과의 신뢰도와 심 사의견의 일치도는 지속적인 관심의 대상이 되어왔다. 왜냐하면, 모 든 심판이 대상자의 수행능력에 대해 유사한 점수를 부여할 수 없 으며, 심사 점수에서 심판 간 차이가 없다고 해도 같은 의견을 가지 고 동일한 항목에 점수를 부여했는지는 알 수 없기 때문이다 (Kim & Jeon, 2018;Choi, 2011;Lee & Kim, 2020) (Fahr et al, 2018).…”