A reanalysis of unpolarized electron-proton elastic scattering data is done in terms of the electric to magnetic form factor squared ratio. This observable is in principle more robust against experimental correlations and global normalizations. The present analysis shows indeed that it is a useful quantity that contains reliable and coherent information. The comparison with the ratio extracted from the measurement of the longitudinal to transverse polarization of the recoil proton in polarized electronproton scattering shows that the results are compatible within the experimental errors. Limits are set on the kinematics where the physical information on the form factors can be safely extracted. The results presented in this work bring a decisive piece of information to the controversy on the deviation of the proton form factors from the dipole dependence.
PACS numbers:Hadron form factors (FFs) contain essential information on the electric and magnetic charge currents in the hadron and constitute a very convenient parametrization that enters in theoretical models and description of experimental observables concerning the three-leg vertex proton-proton-photon. It has been assumed for long time that the proton electric FF, as well as the magnetic FFs of the proton and neutron, normalized to their magnetic moment, have a Q 2 -dipole dependence (Q is the four momentum of the photon):, whereas the neutron electric FF is essentially zero. Evidence for the deviation of the proton electric FF from the dipole form was present since the 70's, in experiments as well as in theory. However, the dipole parametrization was commonly accepted due to the following facts:• From the classical point of view, in the nonrelativistic approximation, FFs are Fourier transforms of the spatial densities of electric charge and magnetization of the nucleon; the dipole approximation corresponds to an exponential distribution and the parameter 0.71 GeV 2 corresponds to a quite reasonable root mean square radius of the proton of 0.81 fm.• From the QCD point of view, as elastic FFs represent the probability that a proton remains in its ground state after that each of its valence quarks has received a momentum squared, Q 2 , transferred by the virtual photon, scaling laws predict a (1/Q 2 ) 2 dependence of the amplitude of the process [1, 2] (corresponding to two gluon exchange, the minimum number of exchanges needed for sharing the momentum among the three valence quarks). * Electronic address: etomasi@cea.frThe reduced cross section of electron-proton elastic scattering, in Born approximation, i.e., by considering only one-photon exchange, σ red , is linear in the variable ǫ = [1 + 2(1 + τ ) tan 2 (θ e /2)] −1 , being θ e the electron scattering angle in the proton rest frame, and τ = Q 2 /(4M 2 ), and it readswhere M is the proton mass, E and dσ/dΩ are the electron initial energy and the differential cross section in the proton rest frame, and G E and G M are the proton electric and magnetic Sachs FFs. The measurement of the differential (reduc...