OBJECTIVE -HNF-1␣ gene mutations (MODY3) present with marked hyperglycemia in lean young adults and may, therefore, be mistaken for type 1 diabetes, with implications for individual treatment and risk of diabetes in other family members. We examined the prevalence of HNF-1␣ mutations in families with three generations of diabetes identified in a populationbased study of childhood diabetes, representing a subpopulation in which misclassification was likely.RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS -In a study population of 1,470 families, 36 families (2.4%) with three affected generations were identified. In the 18 families in whom DNA samples were available, islet autoantibody testing, HLA class II genotyping, and HNF-1␣ sequencing were performed.RESULTS -At least one islet autoantibody was found in 13 of 14 probands, and diabetesassociated HLA class II haplotypes were found in 17 of 18. One proband, who had no islet autoantibodies and was homozygous for the protective HLA haplotype DRB1*02-DQB1*0602, had a novel HNF-1␣ heterozygous nonsense mutation (R54X). This mutation cosegregated with diabetes in the family. The proband, his brother, mother, and maternal grandmother were diagnosed with type 1 diabetes aged 14 -18 years and treated with insulin (0.39 -0.74 units/kg) from diagnosis. The mother has since been successfully transferred to sulfonylurea treatment.CONCLUSIONS -Family history alone is of limited value in identification of individuals with HNF-1␣ mutations, and we propose a stepwise approach that restricts sequencing of the HNF-1␣ gene to those with a family history of diabetes who also test negative for islet autoantibodies.
Diabetes Care 26:333-337, 2003T ype 1 diabetes accounts for the vast majority cases of diabetes in young people, but there are other causes of diabetes in this age-group. Mutations in the hepatocyte nuclear factor (HNF) genes 1␣, 1, and 4␣, causing maturityonset diabetes of the young (MODY), typically present in lean individuals with progressive hyperglycemia and osmotic symptoms in adolescence or early adulthood; therefore, they may be misclassified as type 1 diabetes (1). Mutations in the HNF-1␣ gene account for 65% of MODY in U.K. populations (2) and make up the majority of cases that might be mistaken for type 1 diabetes. The distinction between MODY and type 1 diabetes is important because patients with HNF-1␣ mutations are not insulin dependent and are sensitive to sulfonylureas (3). There are also implications for other family members, since the lifetime incidence of type 1 diabetes in the offspring of an affected parent is estimated at 10% (4), whereas risk to the offspring of an affected parent with MODY is 50%.Type 1 diabetes is characterized by islet autoantibodies that are present at diagnosis in up to 97% of children (5) and by a predisposing HLA genotype. A diagnosis of MODY might therefore be suggested by the absence of islet autoantibodies or the coexistence of class II haplotypes known to confer protection against type 1 diabetes. Of 39 patients identified in a Danish popula...