Analysis and Multiple Steady States of an Industrial Heterogeneous Azeotropic Distillation

Abstract

A study of an industrial multicomponent heterogeneous azeotropic distillation is presented. The process concerns an organic acid dehydration using an immiscible entrainer. First, a validation of the MESH and thermodynamic models through a comparison between pilot-plant experimental reconciled data and simulation results is conducted. A four-component mixture is considered for the simulation. Case studies of the boiler heat duty are automatically generated by an operating path tool. An ∞/∞ analysis is performed for the heterogeneous azeotropic pilot column and an industrial column with a decanter. Because of practical constraints, the pilot and the industrial columns do not have the same reflux policies. This leads the ∞/∞ analysis to predict multiple steady states for the industrial unit but not for the pilot column. However, multiple steady states are found by simulation both for the pilot and for the industrial unit. Multiple steady states are confirmed by simulation and experimental data for the industrial unit. Because of the positive ∞/∞ analysis, they are attributed to the phase equilibrium properties of the quaternary system. For the pilot column, multiple steady states are found by the simulation and linked to experimental observations. The multiplicity is not caused by the phase equilibrium properties; rather, it is attributed to interactions between the material and energy balances. An analysis of the simulation results helps explain the behavior of the industrial unit: the temperature of the sensitive tray gives rise to a peak in heat. This peak is located very close to the industrial temperature set point and is correlated with an impurity content minimum in the main product stream. An impurity minimum is also evidenced by the simulation for the pilot column. This complex behavior can explain observed difficulties in controlling the process at the industrial set point.

Design of a Dividing‐Wall Column Considering its Multiple Steady State Characteristic

“…These extra degrees of freedom also lead to MSS in DWC distillation. This phenomenon has been studied and verified by some researchers . Wayburn and Seader , have been the first to report the existence of MSS in an interlinked separation column, using a differential arc‐length homotopy continuation method.…”

A semicontinuous approach for heterogeneous azeotropic distillation processes

“…In a traditional HAD process, a two-column system is used; the first column is for product separation, and the second is for entrainer recovery (Gaubert et al, 2001;Urdaneta et al, 2002). In addition to the two-column system, some studies provided configurations with three or four consecutive columns, such as in the case of the separation of an ethanol-water mixture using benzene as the entrainer (Ryan and Doherty, 1989;Pham and Doherty, 1990).…”

Dynamic Simulation and Control of a Complete Industrial Acetic Acid Solvent Dehydration System in Purified Terephthalic Acid Production

“…The outcoming HAc solvent containing mainly three components [methyl acetate (MA), PX, and H 2 O] is fed to a solvent dehydration system to recover high-purity HAc and remove the oxidation byproducts. This system is a typical heterogeneous azeotropic distillation system. − Some researchers have found that parametric sensitivity, multiple steady states, long transients, and nonlinear dynamics can exist in this system, − which make this system difficult to design and control. , …”