Analysis and Evaluation of Traffic Congestion Control Methods in Touristic Metropolis Using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)

Abstract

One of the most important issues of urban transport management in metropolitan cities is the control of traffic congestion in the central parts of the city or other densely populated areas. Typical ways to control traffic congestion in metropolitan areas are to create a prohibited traffic area, alternate traffic plan (even and odd), and congestion pricing. In this paper, these traffic congestion control methods have been compared and evaluated. The methodology of this research is analytical hierarchy analysis (AHP). Based on the results, the most effective measures for assessing traffic congestion control methods in metropolitan cities were improving traffic conditions, social welfare, reducing environmental pollution and improving the safety of intra-urban travel. The best Traffic congestion control options were also priced for traffic congestion, roaming traffic (odd and odd), and the creation of traffic barriers. The results of analyzes and paired comparisons in analytic hierarchy analysis were also obtained using “Expert choice” software.

Decision Support System of Performance Appraisal Policy Continuity in the Logistic Staff of Indonesian Armed Force using Discrepancy Evaluation Model and Analytical Hierarchy Process

“…Evaluation provides an overview of learning which is focused on an activity or the delivery of an emphasis. Evaluation is sometimes also used to refer to the study of behavior [11].…”

“…Meanwhile, there are some researches on policy evaluation with the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) which are evaluation studies on traffic congestion control with the AHP approach [11]. The use of the AHP method to develop utility-based evaluation models for management performance in interior environment decoration [12].…”

Multi – criteria analysis of toll collection technologies from a financial and economic aspect

“…AHP метода је широко примењена у саобраћају. Једна је од најчешће коришћених вишекритеријумских метода у избору решења у планирању [10], пројектовању, одржавању [11], реконструкцији саобраћајне инфраструктуре [12] и безбедности саобраћаја [13,14].…”

TCSA: A Traffic Congestion Situation Assessment Scheme Based on Multi-Index Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation in 5G-IoV

“…Shen et al [35] used the mapping relationship between the location traffic parameters and the traffic situations to propose a method for identifying the expressway traffic state based on the projection pursuit dynamic clustering model; Xu et al [36] used graph embedding (GE) to characterize road network information and proposed a higherprecision generative adversarial network model to identify road traffic congestion status. In research on the fuzzy comprehensive method to assess traffic congestion, Kadkhodae et al [37] established the membership function of each evaluation index through in-depth analysis of the characteristics of traffic congestion to determine the weight coefficients based on expert experience and, finally, used fuzzy comprehensive analytic hierarchy to determine the state of traffic congestion. Hao et al [38] proposed a hybrid multi-criteria decision-making method that combined fuzzy analytic hierarchy process, ideal solution similarity ranking preference technology, and gray correlation technology together to verify the effectiveness of the hybrid method through the congestion assessment of intersections.…”