“…Some of the processes enabling C 4 evolution appear to be shared between different lineages Ludwig, 2013), including parallel changes to amino acid sequences (Svensson et al, 2003;Christin et al, 2007Christin et al, , 2008Besnard et al, 2009;Kapralov et al, 2011), common changes to cellspecific expression patterns and regulatory factors John et al, 2014;Williams et al, 2016), and even convergent recruitment of specific gene lineages to the C 4 pathway (Christin et al, 2013(Christin et al, , 2014(Christin et al, , 2015John et al, 2014). The instances of commonality and bias in different C 4 lineages are not surprising, as environmental, anatomical, and metabolic constraints, as well as genome content and structure, limit routes of evolutionary innovation (Weinreich et al, 2006;Christin et al, 2010;Edwards and Donoghue, 2013;Stern, 2013, Storz, 2016.…”