An Organizational Field Approach to Corporate Rationality: The Role of Stakeholder Activism

Abstract

Abstract:This paper contends that rationality is more properly evaluated as a property of an organization’s relationships with its stakeholders than of the organization itself. We predicate our approach on the observation that stakeholders can hold goals quite distinct from those of owners and top managers, and these too can be rationally pursued. We build upon stakeholder theory and Weber’s classic distinction between wertrationalitat and zweckrationalitat, adding to them the “new institutionalist” concept of the organization field (1983, 1991). Stakeholders employ a variety of direct and indirect mechanisms to rationalize relations with the firm. We discuss four: internal subunits, legislated stakeholder participation, legislated access to information, and direct stakeholder activism. These developments are blurring the distinction between the environment and the organization by importing the values and goals of external stakeholders into the internal organization. They are also precipitating a more structured set of relationships among the actors who comprise the field. To the extent that the zweckrationalitat values of managers and owners as well as the wertrationalitat concerns of stakeholders are met, the firm is more rational.

Engaging and marketing to stakeholders in World Heritage Site management: a United Kingdom multiple case study perspective

“…As a result, managers highlight levels of apprehension toward the management partners. Such difficulties are highlighted by similar studies which suggest that a lack of managerial support can lead to mistrust and a lack of faith in the organisations' abilities and intensions (O'Connell, Stephens, Betz, Shepard, & Hendry, 2005).…”

Agency, Information, and the Structure of Moral Problems in Business

“…Where these solutions are not feasible, public policy may require disclosure of financial, environmental, or labor information (O'Connell et al 2005). US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once wrote that 'a little sunshine is the best disinfectant'.…”

Social Contracting in a Pluralist Process of Moral Sense Making: A Dialogic Twist on the ISCT

“…When non-owner stakeholders are taken as constituent members of a pluralist network, which encompasses a shared cooperative purpose as well as a jumble of distinct identities and (often competing) claims, the impulse to ''pluralize'' makes more sense. O'Connell et al (2005) capture the essence of pluralizing at the micro-level when they point to the growing role of stakeholder activism within ''organizational fields. '' DiMaggio and Powell (1983), as leading neo-institutional theorists, developed the concept of the organizational field.…”