“…Like physicians and scientists around the globe, I have been deeply saddened over the past months by the death, destruction and psychological harm wrought on noncombatants across a large swath of the Middle East. However, I was equally distressed by the July 28, 2014 publication in the Lancet , one of the world's leading medical journals, of an anti‐Israel diatribe by Manduca et al entitled “An open letter for the people of Gaza.” Initially, I took a reductionist view of the article: academic journals have no place mixing medicine and science with politics. Indeed, this view was supported by 77.5% of respondents to an August 2014 poll by MedPage Today .…”