An investigation of train driver visual strategies

Abstract

Train driving is primarily a visual task; train drivers are required to monitor the dynamic scene visually both outside and inside the train cab. Poor performance on this visual task may lead to errors, such as signals passed at danger. It is therefore important to understand the visual strategies that train drivers employ when monitoring and searching the visual scene for key items, such as signals. Prior to this investigation, a pilot study had already been carried out using an eye tracking technique to investigate train drivers' visual behaviour and to collect data on driver monitoring of the visual environment, Groeger et al. (2003) Pilot study of train drivers' eye movements, University of Surrey. However, a larger set of data was needed in order to understand more fully train driver visual behaviour and strategies. In light of this need, the Transport Research Laboratory produced a methodology for the assessment of UK train driver visual strategies, on behalf of the Rail Safety and Standards Board and applied this methodology to conduct a large-scale trial. The study collected a wealth of data on train drivers' visual behaviour with the aim of providing a greater understanding of the strategies adopted. The corneal dark-eye tracking system chosen for these trials tracks human visual search and scanning patterns, and was fitted to 86 drivers whilst driving in-service trains. Data collected include the duration and frequency of glances made towards different elements of the visual scene. In addition, the train drivers were interviewed after driving the routes, to try and understand the thought processes behind the behaviour observed. Statistical analysis of over 600 signal approaches was conducted. This analysis revealed that signal aspect, preceding signal aspect, signal type and signal complexity are important factors, which affect the visual behaviour of train drivers. Train driver interview data revealed that driver expectation also plays a significant role in train driving. The findings of this study have implications for the rail industry in terms of infrastructure design, design of the driving task and driver training. However, train driving is extremely complex and the data from this study only begin to describe and explain train driver visual strategies in the specific context of signal approaches. This study has provided a wealth of data and further analysis of it is needed to investigate the role of other factors and the complex relationships between factors during signal approaches and other driving situations systematically. Finally, there are important aspects of visual behaviour that cannot be examined using these data or this method. Investigation of other aspects of visual behaviour, such as peripheral vision, will require other methods such as simulation.

Continuous Feedback as a Key Component of Employee Motivation Improvement - A Railway Case Study based on the Placebo Effect

“…The driving process in itself is also more complicated than it seems [27]. Firstly, shifts are often long (up to 12-14 hours) and provide little or no stimuli other than the repetitive process of accelerating and braking the train, opening the door (in case of passenger trains) and waiting for signals.…”

“…All these requirements stem from the fact that trains are usually very heavy (50 to several thousand times more massive than cars) and often drive at high speeds, which makes for long braking distances and large collision masses and speeds and explains why their consequences are usually very serious. This is also the reason for a very complicated and formalised railway traffic control -the rules of which every driver must know through and through.The driving process in itself is also more complicated than it seems [27]. Firstly, shifts are often long (up to 12-14 hours) and provide little or no stimuli other than the repetitive process of accelerating and braking the train, opening the door (in case of passenger trains) and waiting for signals.…”

<b>Effective Visual Behavior of Railway Drivers for Recognition of Extraordinary Events</b>

“…The remaining time was spent fixating on railway signage and infrastructure, locations beside the track and signals. Luke et al [3] analyzed the visual behaviors of 86 drivers whilst operating in-service trains, revealing that the color of the signal, the color of the next signal, signal type and signal complexity were important factors affecting these behaviors. Naweed et al [4] examined the tasks and activities of urban passenger-train drivers during daily railway driving in order to understand the nature of the visual demand in their task activities.…”

On Human Factors in the Design of Locomotive Cab: An Investigation on Driver’s Cognitive and Behavioral Characteristics

“…After the 2000s, human factors including driver's cognitive characteristics, driving task analysis and its application in cab design began to appear in worldwide literatures. T. Luke et al researched trainman's visual strategies using eye-tracking system and found that signal aspect, preceding signal aspects, signal type and signal complexity affected driver's visual behavior [1].…”