An Investigation of Students’ Use of a Computational Science Simulation in an Online High School Physics Class

Abstract

Science educators have begun to explore how students have opportunities to not only view and manipulate simulations, but also to analyze the complex sources of data they generate. While scholars have documented the characteristics and the effects of using simulations as a source of data in face-to-face, K-12 classrooms, how simulations can be taken up and used in such a way in fully-online classes is less-explored. In this study, we present results from our initial qualitative investigation of students’ use of a simulation in such a way across three lessons in an online, Advanced Placement high school physics class. In all, 13 students participated in the use of a computational science simulation that we adapted to output quantitative data across the lesson sequence. Students used the simulation and developed a class data set, which students then used to understand, interpret, and model a thermodynamics-related concept and phenomenon. We explored the progression of students’ conceptual understanding across the three lessons, students’ perceptions of the strengths and weaknesses of the simulation, and how students balanced explaining variability and being able to interpret their model of the class data set. Responses to embedded assessment questions indicated that a few developed more sophisticated conceptual understanding of the particle nature of matter and how it relates to diffusion, while others began the lesson sequence with an already-sophisticated understanding, and a few did not demonstrate changes in their understanding. Students reported that the simulation helped to make a complex idea more accessible and useful and that the data generated by the simulation made it easier to understand what the simulation was representing. When analyzing the class data set, some students focused on fitting the data, not considering the interpretability of the model as much, whereas other students balanced model fit with interpretability and usefulness. In all, findings suggest that the lesson sequence had educational value, but that modifications to the design of the simulation and lesson sequence and to the technologies used could enhance its impact. Implications and recommendations for future research focus on the potential for simulations to be used to engage students in a variety of scientific and engineering practices in online science classes.

Impact of computer modeling on learning and teaching systems thinking

“…Computer modeling may help enrich systems thinking by highlighting the central phenomena of a system (Damelin, Krajcik, Mcintyre, & Bielik, 2017; Dickes, Sengupta, Farris, & Basu, 2016; Jordan et al, 2018) and deepening students' argumentation around systems mechanisms (Damelin et al, 2017; Rosenberg & Lawson, 2019). Computer tools, such as data logging systems, graphing tools, simulation, and modeling environments, may also influence learning by affording changes in classroom interactions (Kim, Hannafin, & Bryan, 2007; Maor & Taylor, 1995).…”

More confidently uncertain? Teaching learners to apply Bayesian methods to make sense of scientific phenomena

“…In particular, I began a National Science Foundation-funded project focused on providing greater opportunities for students to be involved in computer science (in light of new K-8 computer science and computational thinking standards in the state of Tennessee). Building on earlier work about how students model data from a computational science simulation (Rosenberg & Lawson, 2019), I have also begun to explore the role of data science in education through in scholarship (Rosenberg et al, 2020b). This work has collectively emphasized the potential utility to students of more accessible and useful statistical methods in science education contexts.…”

Millennial Lecturer in Higher Education: The Effect of Knowledge Clusters, Performance and Learning Satisfaction on Learning Outcomes

“…As for the learning platform with Learning Management Systems [5]. the challenge of creating, modifying, and analyzing data generated from simulations in online classes, it is important that we know more about how students use simulations and model the data they generate in online learning environments [6].…”