Groin hernias are very common and were previously thought to all need operative repair. They are the most common surgical condition encountered by primary care clinicians, with 1.6 million diagnosed annually and 500 000 undergoing operative repair in the United States. 1 The lifetime risk of groin hernia ranges from 27% for men to 3% for women and follows a bimodal distribution at the extremes of life. 1 The term groin hernia encompasses 3 types depending on location: indirect inguinal, direct inguinal, and femoral. It is difficult to determine which type of groin hernia is present before surgery, but it is also not necessary to know because the operative repair is similar for each.Determining which patients require operative repair is challenging. Historically, operative repair for all groin hernias was recommended based on anecdotal experiences and the assumption that hernias would enlarge over time and have high recurrence rates after delayed repair. Moreover, the concern for acute incarceration involving intestinal contents leading to bowel obstruction, ischemia, and need for emergency operation propagated this sentiment. Over time, the concept of "watchful waiting" emerged for select patients who wish to forgo elective operative intervention after an informed discussion of the relevant risks and benefits of not pursuing operative repair of groin hernias. Box. Ideal Candidate Characteristics and Counseling Points for Patients Desiring Watchful Waiting Candidate Characteristics Male sex Absent or minimal discomfort Hernia is completely reducible Patient preference to forgo operation Counseling Points Low chance of presentation as surgical emergency (1.8 per 1000 person-years) As many as 70% of patients may ultimately undergo repair, usually because of pain Similar surgical outcomes for patients who crossed over compared with those who underwent primary repair Advise risk factor modification: smoking cessation, medical optimization, weight loss Not associated with increased costs of care No evidence that physical activity results in a hernia incarceration or clinical worsening of an existing hernia Clinical Review & Education