An integrated view of human, organizational, and technological challenges of IT security management

Abstract

Purpose-The purpose of this study is to determine the main challenges that IT security practitioners face in their organizations, including the interplay among human, organizational, and technological factors. Design/methodology/approach-The data set consisted of 36 semi-structured interviews with IT security practitioners from 17 organizations (academic, government, and private). The interviews were analyzed using qualitative description with constant comparison and inductive analysis of the data to identify the challenges that security practitioners face. Findings-A total of 18 challenges that can affect IT security management within organizations are indentified and described. This analysis is grounded in related work to build an integrated framework of security challenges. The framework illustrates the interplay among human, organizational, and technological factors. Practical implications-The framework can help organizations identify potential challenges when implementing security standards, and determine if they are using their security resources effectively to address the challenges. It also provides a way to understand the interplay of the different factors, for example, how the culture of the organization and decentralization of IT security trigger security issues that make security management more difficult. Several opportunities for researchers and developers to improve the technology and processes used to support adoption of security policies and standards within organizations are provided. Originality/value-A comprehensive list of human, organizational, and technological challenges that security experts have to face within their organizations is presented. In addition, these challenges within a framework that illustrates the interplay between factors and the consequences of this interplay for organizations are integrated.

Failure Factors of ERP Projects in an Iranian Context

“…Based on the results of the intial interviews, the following conceptual framework is designed as the basis of the open-ended questionnaire to collect qualitative data from 40 respendents in next step . The autors develop the conceptual framework based on the model of Human,Organization and Technology that previously used for several studies about IT security voulnerability [23] The 40 respondents of this study are selected from IT, operation and production departments of the Iranian manufacturing industries.…”

An Enterprise Anti-phishing Framework

“…While technology is important, organizational and human factors also form a crucial role in achieving information security [1]. Understanding of how different human, organizational, and technological elements interplay could explain how different factors lead to sources of security breaches and vulnerabilities within organizations [15], [30]. Since each dimension has human involvement, even if the organizational dimension is added, protection may not be sufficient as both the organizational and technology dimensions depend on the H dimension.…”

“…It is the responsibility of all employees to protect information thus defending the reputation and financial wellbeing of the business [2]. Effective interactions and communications are required to reach a mutual understanding about security risks among different stakeholders [30]. An information security culture needs to be adopted to ensure that information security becomes a natural aspect in the daily practice of every employee.…”

Organizational factors’ effects on the success of e-learning systems and organizational benefits: An empirical study in Taiwan

“…Information security is an interdisciplinary field encompassing aspects of organization, management, and technology (Werlinger, Hawkey, & Beznosov, 2009). Most efforts in this field have been traditionally dedicated to technical or managerial issues.…”