An Explanation for the Sensitivity of the Mean State of the Community Atmosphere Model to Horizontal Resolution on Aquaplanets

Abstract

The sensitivity of the mean state of the Community Atmosphere Model to horizontal resolutions typical of present-day general circulation models is investigated in an aquaplanet configuration. Nonconvergence of the mean state is characterized by a progressive drying of the atmosphere and large reductions in cloud coverage with increasing resolution. Analyses of energy and moisture budgets indicate that these trends are balanced by variations in moisture transport by the resolved circulation, and a reduction in activity of the convection scheme. In contrast, the large-scale precipitation rate increases with resolution, which is approximately balanced by greater advection of dry static energy associated with more active resolved vertical motion in the ascent region of the Hadley cell. An explanation for the sensitivity of the mean state to horizontal resolution is proposed, based on linear Boussinesq theory. The authors hypothesize that an increase in horizontal resolution in the model leads to a reduction in horizontal scale of the diabatic forcing arising from the column physics, facilitating finescale flow and faster resolved convective updrafts within the dynamical core, and steering the coupled system toward a new mean state. This hypothesis attempts to explain the underlying mechanism driving the variations in moisture transport observed in the simulations.

NCAR Release of CAM‐SE in CESM2.0: A Reformulation of the Spectral Element Dynamical Core in Dry‐Mass Vertical Coordinates With Comprehensive Treatment of Condensates and Energy

“…It is plausible, however, that a less intuitive relationship between divergence damping and precipitation may emerge in a more realistic configuration, acknowledging that Zhao et al () have reported on a counterintuitive relationship to tropical storm genesis. In our aqua‐planet simulations, the ITCZ, in part, consists of underresolved, deep convective towers simulated by the resolved dynamics, consistent with a prior study of CAM‐HOMME (Herrington & Reed, ). The base of the convective towers often originates within the boundary layer, with convergent flow‐driving resolved upward mass fluxes through the cloud base.…”

The Summertime Precipitation Bias in E3SM Atmosphere Model Version 1 over the Central United States

“…The ne30_NE30TP and the RRM_NE30TP simulations have similar total precipitable water, cloud water path, surface evaporation, total precipitation rate, and precipitation efficiency; in contrast, the RRM_NE120TP simulations have clearly higher cloud water path, lower surface evaporation, lower total precipitation rate, and lower precipitation efficiency. The convective precipitation ratio is reduced as the model horizontal resolution increases and the time step decreases in both CAPT and AMIP simulations, which is consistent with previous studies (e.g.,Bacmeister et al, ; Herrington & Reed, ; Tang et al, ). Williamson () argued that if the model time step becomes too short compared with the relaxation time scales in the convection schemes, the extreme precipitation from intense, truncation‐scale storms will increase.…”

Sensitivity of Mountain Hydroclimate Simulations in Variable‐Resolution CESM to Microphysics and Horizontal Resolution

“…One proposal to alleviate this issue is to push climate models to the highest grid‐spacings possible, typically utilizing modern exascale computing systems (Reed & Dongarra, ). This has resulted in a recent surge in research and development addressing multi‐scale modeling (Iorio et al, ; O'Brien et al, ; Tao et al, ), scale‐aware physics (Fan et al, ; Gross et al, ; Herrington & Reed, ; Randall et al, ), and atmospheric models that span hydrostatic and nonhydrostatic scales (Ferguson et al, ; Heinzeller et al, ; Herrington & Reed, ; Park et al, ).…”