An Experimental and Theoretical Study of a Coupling Mechanism Between Longitudinal and Torsional Drillstring Vibrations at the Bit

Abstract

Summary. A mechanism that couples longitudinal and torsional drillstring vibrations at the bit was studied. Torsional vibrations are associated with dynamic variations of the rotational bit speed. When a roller bit runs over a multilobed pattern, these speed variations have been shown to affect the input of longitudinal vibrations. The theory for this coupling mechanism is verified experimentally by high-rate data of near-bit accelerations and torque recorded in a 1000-m [3,280-ft] -deep well. Introduction Several publications have dealt with vibrations in drillstrings. As discussed in the literature, vibrations influence the drilling situation and can result in a lower rate of penetration or may cause fatigue failures. On the other hand, a thorough understanding of the vibrations can enable predictions of downhole conditions on the basis of top measurements. The theory presented here is an attempt to explain some phenomena seen in experiments performed at Ullrigg, a full-scale offshore-type research drilling rig. These experiments comprise both real drilling and "drilling" with an exciter system, which induces a longitudinal, sinusoidal vibration with a constant amplitude at the bit. The experimental setup with data transmission system is thoroughly described in Ref. 1. Frequency spectra on drilling data gathered at Ullrigg often contain small side lobes near the most dominant frequency components. The sources for these side lobes are also discussed here. Theory It is assumed here that the axial motion of the bit can be described by an elevation function, s(s theta), where s theta is the angular displacement of the bit. Assuming also that the shape and orientation of the downhole patterns do not change or at least change very slowly with time implies that ,............................(1) where n is an integer. The axial force through the bit, or weight on bit (WOB), can formally be written as ,............................(2) where F denotes the mean force and F denotes the dynamic or fluctuating force. The torque on bit (TOB) may also be separated into a mean torque, tau, and a dynamic part that is represented by ,............................(3) Because of this dynamic torque, the rotation rate of the bit will fluctuate about a mean value omega: ,............................(4) where omega = omega(tau) may be regarded as a dynamic torsional response to the input torque tau. Now, turning to the special case where the downhole patterns are pure sinusoidal three-lobed patterns with amplitude s1, the axial bit motion can be written as .............................(5) Note that Eq. 5 is correct only with a three-cone roller bit and if the roller radius is much smaller than the pattern curvature radius. This requirement is reasonably well satisfied for the exciter system, where s1 = 2 mm [0.08 in.]. In the first linear approximation, it is assumed that the dynamic variations of force and bit speed are negligibly small--i.e., .............................................(6) and .............................................(7) The input for axial and torsional vibrations is then decoupled and may be written as .......................................(8) and ........................................(9) The negative sign appears because the torque input--i.e., the torque transfer from the formation to the bit--is minus the TOB. Hence, the dynamic torque input is positive when the bit is running downward on a negative slope: ds/ds theta less than 0. Eq. 8 has been used in several earlier publications on drillstring vibrations. Experiments have revealed, however, that the assumptions for this first linear approximation are poorly satisfiedi.e., the dynamic force, F, and the dynamic speed, omega, are not negligibly small. Hence the displacement, ,...................................(10) and the torsional excitation moment, ,............................(11) SPEDE

Whirl Interaction of a Drill Bit with the Bore-Hole Bottom

“…His analyses demonstrated that conventional PDC bits tend to whirl backward, while anti-whirl PDC bits effectively reduce this tendency and whirl forward. The possibility to vibrate with backward and forward whirlings was noted also by Schen et al [11] and Thor Viggo and Age [12]. In their observations, the whirl rotation occurred several times per revolution of the bit and during whirl, the bit drilled an overgage hole with a multilobed cross-section.…”

“…The techniques used for analysis of equation system (1), (3), (4), (12), and (21), as stated above, represent an implicit computational algorithm of integration. It is absolutely stable for any time increment t ∆ of the integration process but to provide the satisfactory accuracy, it should be fairly small.…”

Stick–slip vibrations in oil well drillstring: A review

“…For the drilling industry, comprehensive experimental facilities have been developed to characterize the bit performance. 99 These facilities have improved the understanding of the interaction between the drill bit and rock formation, resulting in high performance drilling tool and proper operation. The investigations reviewed in the following section focuses on the experimental studies of stick–slip vibrations in drillstring.…”

Laboratory investigation of drillstring vibrations

“…Other experimental drillstrings constructed for laboratory investigations have been reported in the literature. Aarrestad and Kyllingstad [12,13] constructed a full-scale 1000 m vertical research drillstring for studying the coupling between axial and torsional vibrations at the BHA. They used a vertical drillstring and utilized a hard-wire measurement-while-drilling (MWD) tool.…”