An ethical analysis of how ESL teachers construct their professional identities through the use of information technology in teaching

Abstract

While there is growing recognition of the mutually shaping relationship between teaching with information technology (IT) and teachers’ beliefs, skills and self‐efficacy, there has been a paucity of research attention on the construction of teacher identity during actual IT‐assisted in‐class teaching and out‐of‐class networking with students, in a full institutional and social context. This study investigates how a group of secondary school English as a second language (ESL) teachers regulated their teaching and practices and constructed their identities in relation to governmental requirements for the use of IT in teaching. Teachers from seven government‐subsidised schools in Hong Kong were interviewed about their experiences of using IT in teaching. We frame the reported practices of these teachers as a process of construction of identity, formed in the context of the ‘governmentality’ supporting current examination‐oriented educational policy. Observing from the perspective of what has been termed ‘governmentality’ and an ethical framework for self‐formation of personal identity makes it possible to see these teachers’ professional identities constructed through the use of IT practices within the contradictory conditions of professional/personal demands, compliance/resistance, school promotion/peer non‐cooperation, advantage/disadvantage in use of IT, use of IT/content and pedagogical knowledge. This study has implications for developing a more supportive and rational environment for the use of IT in teaching, in which more autonomy and identity options—rather than constraints—can be provided for teachers in the digital era. This study also informs practitioners and policy makers in other educational settings experiencing a similar IT boom in teaching.

The Covid-19 pandemic and its effects on teacher education in England: how teacher educators moved practicum learning online

“…Somekh 2007;Kali, McKenney, and Sagy 2015). Research also explored how technologies frame professional learning for students and educators (Murray and Kidd 2016) or the use of online tools for teaching and personal learning (Bergviken et al 2018;Gu and Lai 2019). But in a systematic review of research into online ITE (pre-pandemic), Dyment and Downing (2020, 329) conclude that 'the present research base is fragmented and consists of disparate and unrelated studies that rarely cross-reference each other'.…”

The Professional Development of Academic Staff in Higher Education Institution

“…However, only a few approaches have been assessed in order to determine the strengths and weaknesses of peer review of teaching (Biasutti, Baz, & Alshawa, 2016). Therefore, research efforts have been exerted to explore the interplay between different forms of power, practices of policy and teacher identity (as cited in Gu & Lai, 2019).…”

Ethical Research Dilemmas and Their Implications In English Language Teaching Studies

“…They found that the students and teachers had different perceptions about the application of those ethical principles, including discipline according to law and school policy. Gu and Lai (2019) investigates secondary school English (ESL) teachers regulated their teaching and practices and constructed their identities in relation to governmental requirements for the use of IT in teaching. They found that there was an identity dilemma for teachers.…”