An Empirical Study of the Casual Relationship Between IT Investment and Firm Performance

Abstract

The promise of increased competitive advantage has been the driving force behind the large-scale investment in information technology (IT) over the last three decades. There is a continuing debate among executives and academics as to the measurable benefits of this investment. The return on investment (ROI) and other performance measures reported in the academic literature indicate conflicting empirical findings. Many previous studies have based their conclusions on the statistical correlation between IT capital investment and firm performance data of the same time period. In this study we argue that the causal relationship between IT investment and firm performance could not be reliably established through concurrent IT and performance data. We further submit that it would be more convincing to infer causality if the IT investments in the preceding years are significantly correlated with the performance of a firm in the subsequent year. Using the Granger causality models and three samples of firm level financial data, we found no statistical evidence that IT investments have caused the improvement of financial performance of the firms in the samples. On the contrary, the causal models suggest that improved financial performance over consecutive years may have contributed to the increase of IT investment in the subsequent year. Implications of these findings, as well as directions for future studies, are discussed.

Evaluating the impact of IT investments on productivity: a causal analysis at industry level

“…That is, investments in IT lead to better performance, and better performance in turn leads to higher IT investments. While some later studies have also noted the possibility of this reverse causality between IT investments and firm performance measures (Kraemer & Dedrick, 1993;Siegel, 1997;Sircar, Turnbow, & Bordoloi, 2000;Hu & Plant, 2001;Shin, 2001;Hitt, Wu, & Zhou, 2002), only a few have explicitly tested the existence of this relationship. Weill (1992), for instance, tested the relationship with the data collected from the US valve manufacturing industry.…”

The Benefits of Using E‐business Technology: The Supplier Perspective

“…A review of this literature reveals mixed results (Hu and Plant 2001). A study by Hitt and Brynjolfsson (l996) finds that the inconsistencies observed among various studies can be attributed to variations in methods and measures used in the analyses.…”

Modeling the Relationship Between Firm It Capability, Collaboration, and Performance

“…A review of the IT literature reveals mixed results with respect to the impact of IT on firm financial performance (Hu and Plant 2001). A study by Hitt and Brynjolfsson (l996) finds that the inconsistencies observed among various studies can be attributed to variations in methods and measures used in the analyses.…”