An emerging economy perspective on corporate sustainability reporting – main actors’ views on the current state of affairs in Pakistan

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to explore the main actors' views on the current state of sustainability reporting in a developing country context. This qualitative study is based on the interviews of 20 individuals and organizations from Pakistan who were identified as main actors involved in the practice of sustainability reporting. This paper draws on the arguments of multiple theoretical frameworks, including legitimacy theory, stakeholders' theory, institutional theory, political cost theory, and signalling theory. Following a semi-structured interview protocol, main actors were asked to share their views on the drivers and barriers of sustainability reporting, sufficiency and suitability of sustainability-related regulation and standards, perceived benefits of sustainability reporting, level of stakeholder engagement and transparency. Interviews were then analysed to compare the viewpoints of different stakeholder groups on various issues. This paper concludes that, like other emerging and developing economies, the practice of sustainability reporting is largely driven by the external forces. Foreign buyers, international professional associations and standard-setting organizations are playing a pivotal role in the emergence and development of sustainability reporting. Sustainability reporting awards also played an important role as they provide the normative basis and intangible benefits for reporting. Despite these external forces driving the emergence and development of SR in Pakistan, the structural and cultural conditions that exist in the societal context of Pakistan significantly impact the disclosure practices and organizational rationales for SR. In particular, weak government structures, lack of awareness and interest in sustainability matters, lack of regulation, lack of enforcement capabilities, lack of a political will has been identified as the main barriers of SR. The paper explores the perceptions of both managerial and non-managerial stakeholders regarding the current state of sustainability reporting in Pakistan.

Potential applications of unmanned ground and aerial vehicles to mitigate challenges of transport and logistics-related critical success factors in the humanitarian supply chain

“…This is exploratory qualitative research, designed to uncover trends in thought and opinions, and identify the problem currently being faced by different Humanitarian organizations during disaster relief (Wyse 2011). Moreover, Mahmood et al (2019) Also suggest that qualitative methods help to capture not only the stakeholders' perception but also elaborate on the context in which they are held. Therefore, to answer the research questions drafted for this study, we used the data triangulation approach.…”

Sustainability Reporting and Firm Performance: The Demonstration of Pakistani Firms

“…The study indicated a positive impact of sustainable financial reporting on firm financial performance and concluded that enhanced financial performance of banks in Pakistan is connected with increase in sustainable financial reporting. A qualitative study was carried out by Mahmood et al (2019) to identify actors involved in sustainable financial reporting in Pakistan. Results suggested that local and international regulatory agencies, standards, foreign buyers, and sustainable reporting awards are important actors in the development and emergence of sustainable financial reporting in Pakistan.…”

Institutional logics and practice variations in sustainability reporting: evidence from an emerging field

“…We believe that these inherent tensions between long-established traditional institutions and the emergence of modern institutions have both direct and indirect impacts on the institutional logics and practices of sustainability reporting, which require exploration. In addition, the study on sustainability reporting in a context where very few companies comply even with mandatory disclosure requirements is indeed illuminating (Mahmood et al, 2017;Mahmood et al, 2019) The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 presents a review of the literature, focusing mainly on the competing nature of the sustainability construct and its reporting, as well as the diversity of practices and motivations.…”