An assessment of key sustainability competencies: a review of scales and propositions for validation

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to review and provide propositions about survey assessment tools of the key sustainability competencies (KSCs) of education for sustainability. UNESCO points out how education plays an important role in transforming societies towards a sustainable future and achieving the United Nations’ sustainable development goals. To plan education for sustainability, teachers need to know the students’ competencies for sustainability before they come to class. Thus, a formative assessment about student competence for sustainability is needed. Design/methodology/approach Firstly, a structured literature review of assessment tools used to measure sustainability competencies by questionnaire survey is presented. Secondly, the authors’ conceptualise how the competencies influence each other and provide propositions for future research. Findings The literature demonstrates that there is much ambiguity between prior research about the scales used and what they represent. A lack of validation across disciplines is apparent and an assessment tool that includes all eight KSCs could benefit education for sustainability. Future research could investigate how the competencies influence each other and which drivers are stronger for each discipline across different countries. A formative assessment tool can address this need. Originality/value The findings provide a new analysis about questionnaire assessment tools used in prior research to measure sustainability competence. The authors’ offer a discussion about the strengths and weaknesses found in prior research and propose suggestions for future research. Their conceptualisation also provides propositions for validating the KSCs presented in a recent framework.

Education for Sustainability—Some Bibliometric Insights

“…An example of a positive practice for broadening awareness of the sustainability phenomenon is the integration of a training process for university teachers, which subsequently facilitates them to link the topic of environmental protection with the content of the educational process and the overall political and social context [25], and the building of competences to connect work and expertise with the sustainability imperative has become a challenge [26]. At the same time, teachers need to determine the state of students' knowledge of sustainability before the start of the course by providing appropriate tools to measure key sustainability competences [27]. Teaching methods are also subject to scrutiny as learners need to consider interconnected, multi-faceted aspects of sustainability, whereas a traditional case study generally presents a single situation to consider [28].…”

Connecting Didactic Approaches and Sustainability Competencies: Evidence from a Teacher Education Institution in Vietnam

“…Gordon and Thomas (2018) recommend roleplay as a powerful technique to developing sustainability competencies. Annelin (2021) examines the positive impacts of experiential learning on sustainability competencies in the context of higher education. Wang et al (2022) empirically tests whether universal and broadly applicable pedagogies like case studies, interdisciplinary team teaching, lecturing, mind and concept maps, project and/or problem-based learning can help to develop students' sustainability competencies.…”

Efforts by Universities to Promote Sustainability Competence Over The Last Few Decades : A Systematic Literature Review

“…The SLR focused on SC totaled seventh articles (by searching using "sustainability competence" AND review" in the Scopus database). SLR relates to an assessment of key SC (Annelin & Boström, 2022), human competencies (Galleli et al, 2020), and the urgency of green skills and SC (Montanari et al, 2023). So far, only two SLR-based articles have been found that are related to higher education, i.e.…”