An Approach to Analysis of Expert Estimation Validity in Cognitive Mapping

Abramova, Nina; Telitsyna, Tatyana

doi:10.3182/20130619-3-ru-3018.00497

Cited by 4 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 4 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…It consists in the inevitable and significant participation of people (experts, stakeholders, moderators) in solving problems through formal methods. The practical significance of this problem in cognitive mapping is justified and empirically confirmed [6], [11], [12]. Not only do researchers in cognitive mapping directly or indirectly talk about risks for validity (or directly errors), but also in the related area of system dynamics [13], [14]; different approaches are proposed to reduce the role of risks in the construction of cognitive maps.…”

Section: Collective Cognitive Map Construction 21 the State Of The mentioning

confidence: 99%

“…• Rejection of the typical procedure for the CCM construction: a formal integration of several cognitive maps by averaging the influence weights. It is caused by a lack of knowledge of acceptable validity necessary for estimating influences' weights in the map (confirmed by studies on the expert estimation problem in cognitive mapping [12]).…”

Section: The Main Ideas Of Our Approachmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

On approach to the agreement of diverse stakeholders’ interests and goals in the governance

Avdeeva¹,

Kovriga²

2018

IJET

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The paper proposes the use of a collective cognitive map when solving governance problems as an effective means of diverse stakeholders’ interests and goals agreement. For compose such a map, an original approach is proposed that combines (1) the clarification and agreement of stakeholder representations on the governance problem using a number of criteria for improving the map quality and (2) the clusterization of similar stakeholder representations.

show abstract

Section: Collective Cognitive Map Construction 21 the State Of The mentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: The Main Ideas Of Our Approachmentioning

confidence: 99%

On approach to the agreement of diverse stakeholders’ interests and goals in the governance

Avdeeva¹,

Kovriga²

2018

IJET

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Multicriteria decision-making tasks based on hierarchy analysis have been discussed to improve the consistency of experts (Khatwani and Kar, 2016) and establish the accuracy of expert evaluation of the object state by pairwise comparison with a quantitative assessment of preferences (Radaev, 2007). The consistency of expert evaluations is established by mapping on a Cartesian plane (Abramova and Telitsyna, 2013;Wilson et al, 2018;Risvik et al, 1994;Hopfer and Heymann, 2013).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Study of consistency of expert evaluations of wine sensory characteristics by positional analysis

Khalafyan

Темердашев

Akinshina

et al. 2021

Heliyon

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Individual characteristics inherent in the expert, as well as their physical and psycho-emotional state subject to the influence of random, uncontrollable factors, contribute to subjectivity in the sensory evaluation of wines. With great variability of opinions, the final results of sensory evaluation may become doubtful. The presence of a random component in the sensory evaluation justifies the use of statistical methods for analyzing the consistency of expert evaluations. Along with Spearman's correlation coefficients and Kendall matching, Cronbach alpha criterion was used to assess the consistency of expert opinions. The advantages of positional analysis have been discussed -Cronbach's alpha criterion is calculated not by the rank of expert points, but by the initial point scale considering its variability; it allows to evaluate the contribution of each expert to the consistency of expert evaluations, as well as the reliability of the total scale of points set for each wine sample. Based on the data analysis from sensory evaluation of the quality of dry red and white wines of Russian production, the results of the consistency study of expert evaluations as well as the reliability of the total score scale have been presented. What is more, analysis of the "loyalty" of experts in evaluating the quality of wines has been performed.

show abstract

Learning large-scale fuzzy cognitive maps using an evolutionary many-task algorithm

Wang

Liu

et al. 2021

Applied Soft Computing

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

An Approach to Analysis of Expert Estimation Validity in Cognitive Mapping

Cited by 4 publications

References 4 publications

On approach to the agreement of diverse stakeholders’ interests and goals in the governance

On approach to the agreement of diverse stakeholders’ interests and goals in the governance

Study of consistency of expert evaluations of wine sensory characteristics by positional analysis

Learning large-scale fuzzy cognitive maps using an evolutionary many-task algorithm

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About