An analysis of structure, organization and delivery of ICU care in Bangladesh

Abstract

Background : This study is a sub analysis of data submitted on behalf of Bangladesh to an international study (2013-2014) involving Asian ICUs and merits comparison with prior study done in Bangladesh in 2007 which had similar objective.
 Objective : To assess structure, organization and delivery of ICU care in ICUs of Bangladesh with attention to hospital organizational characteristics, ICU organizational characteristics, staffing etc.
 Method : Prospective cohort study involving ICUs of 51 hospitals of Bangladesh done in 2013-2014. The hospitals in our study were divided into three groups : clinics/hospitals less than 50 beds (n =18), clinics/hospitals more than 50 beds(n=24) and Govt. hospitals/academic hospitals/ medical colleges hospitals (n=9).
 Results : Most respondent hospitals were from Dhaka (77.4%). Only 17.6% hospitals were university affiliated. The average number of hospital beds were 225. The average number of ICU beds were 14. 19.6 % hospitals had infection control committees. Basic life support training was required for doctors and nurses in 31.4 % and 27.5 % hospitals respectively. Small clinics/ hospitals (less than 50 bed capacity [n=18]) had significantly less government funding (p < 0.0001), were less attached to university hospital (p < 0.0001), had fewer referral centers (p < 0.001), had less total hospital beds (p < 0.004) and were less in case of ICU beds : hospital beds percentage (p < 0.003). 28 ICUs had no single room. Govt. hospitals/academic hospitals/Medical colleges had relatively more ICU beds .(12.33% - p < 0.004). 60.8% ICUs were operated as open units. Open units were more likely present in hospitals/clinics more than 50 beds. Multivariable analysis showed that the presence of 1:1 nursing staff was much lower in private hospitals. Funding sources and types of hospitals were independently associated with lower percentage of ICU beds (p < 0.002) and (p < 0.0001) respectfully. University affiliations was more likely associated with closed ICU (p < 0.002). Presence of MD CCM qualified intensivists are more in government funded hospitals (p < 0.003) than those of private hospitals
 Conclusions : Our study demonstrates considerable variation in the organization and staffing among Bangladeshi ICUs. Compared to 2007 study it shows increased trend in number of closed units( 39% vs 15%) and percentage of ICU beds relative to number of hospital beds (6.5% vs 4.8%) .
 Bangladesh Crit Care J March 2019; 7(1): 3-11

The story of critical care in Asia: a narrative review

“…The Saudi Critical Care Trials Group (SCCTG) has produced several highimpact papers [20][21][22] In addition, the reach of research led by the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine (ESICM) Trials Group, the Australian and New Zealand Intensive Care Society (ANZICS) Clinical Trials Group, the Canadian Critical Care Trials Group (CCCTG), and WFICC has extended to Asia [23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30]. Significantly, after an inaugural multinational effort on the Management Of Severe sepsis in Asia's Intensive Care unitS (MOSAICS) study [31], the ACCCT Group was formed in 2012 and has since conducted studies in 28 Asian countries and regions [9,11,[32][33][34][35][36], some of which have also published their own national data from these studies [37][38][39][40][41].…”

Critical care bed capacity of Bangladesh: A Pre and Post COVID-19 pandemic survey

“…We have observed that there are many districts with limited number of hospital beds also have no critical care facilities in those hospitals. It is also our observation from literature search that Bangladesh suffers from lack of sufficient trained doctors and nurses in critical care delivery 4 .…”

“…In 2013 -14 another study was done in Bangladesh involving 51 ICUs as apart of broader international study named as AISP study 3 . The Bangladesh part of the study was done with data from districts of Dhaka, Sylhet, Chattogram, Mymensingh and Savar and it involved 748 adult, pediatric and neonatal ICU beds 4 .…”

Preventing unrecognized deterioration & improving outcomes of critically ill patients using the National Early Warning Score 2 in a high dependency unit in Bangladesh: A quality improvement project

“…10,11 However, the field of critical care struggles, as this sector lacks proper infrastructure, appropriate facilities and adequate qualified staff. 9,10,12,13 There is limited provision of formal teaching and training of critical care nursing staff, 9,12,13 especially in the realm of recognition of sudden patient deterioration. 9,13 Early Warning Scores, calculated from regularly observed bedside physiological parameters, have been proven to be a valuable tool to assess disease severity and prompt decision making.…”

“…9,10,12,13 There is limited provision of formal teaching and training of critical care nursing staff, 9,12,13 especially in the realm of recognition of sudden patient deterioration. 9,13 Early Warning Scores, calculated from regularly observed bedside physiological parameters, have been proven to be a valuable tool to assess disease severity and prompt decision making. 5 Such a scoring system does not require any costly investigation or invasive procedure, is easy to measure and document, and so is appropriate for resource limited settings.…”