“…Although, it has been criticized by some scholars (Beaver et al, 2007;Dechow et al, 2003;Easton, 2005, 2009;Holland, 2004;Lahr, 2014;McNichols, 2003), it has been widely used in the literature (Baber and Kang, 2002;Beatty et al, 2002;Brown and Caylor, 2004;Collins et al, 1999;Coppens and Peek, 2005;Daske et al, 2006;Degeorge et al, 1999;Easton, 1999;Gore et al, 2007;Hamdi and Zarai, 2012;Hayn, 1995;Holland and Ramsay, 2003;Huang and Hsiao, 2011;Jacob and Jorgensen, 2007;Kerstein and Rai, 2007;Marques et al, 2011;Moreira, 2006;Phillips et al, 2004;Poli, 2013aPoli, , b, 2015aRevsine et al, 2009).…”