25For carbon capture and storage to successfully contribute to climate mitigation efforts, the 26 captured and stored CO2 must be securely isolated from the atmosphere and oceans for a 27 minimum of 10,000 years. As it is not possible to undertake experiments over such timescales, 28here we investigate natural occurrences of CO2, trapped for 10 4 -10 6 yr to understand the 29 geologic controls on long term storage performance. We present the most comprehensive 30 natural CO2 reservoir dataset compiled to date, containing 76 naturally occurring natural CO2 31 stores, located in a range of geological environments around the world. We use this dataset 32to perform a critical analysis of the controls on long-term CO2 retention in the subsurface. We 33 find no evidence of measureable CO2 migration at 66 sites and hence use these sites as 34 examples of secure CO2 retention over geological timescales. We find unequivocal evidence 35 of CO2 migration to the Earth's surface at only 6 sites, with inconclusive evidence of migration 36 at 4 reservoirs. Our analysis shows that successful CO2 retention is controlled by: thick and 37 multiple caprocks, reservoir depths of >1200m, and high density CO2. Where CO2 has 38 migrated to surface, the pathways by which it has done so are focused along faults, illustrating 39 that CO2 migration via faults is the biggest risk to secure storage. However, we also find that 40 many naturally occurring CO2 reservoirs are fault bound illustrating that faults can also 41 securely retain CO2 over geological timescales. Hence, we conclude that the sealing ability of 42 fault or damage zones to CO2 must be fully characterised during the appraisal process to fully 43 assess the risk of CO2 migration they pose. We propose new engineered storage site selection 44 criteria informed directly from on our observations from naturally occurring CO2 reservoirs. 45These criteria are similar to, but more prescriptive than, existing best-practise guidance for 46 selecting sites for engineered CO2 storage and we believe that if adopted will increase CO2 47 storage security in engineered CO2 stores.