Amphibious Encounters: Coral and People in Conservation Outreach in Indonesia

Abstract

Drawing on long-term ethnographic research in Indonesia, this article describes a conservation outreach project that attempts to educate and convert local people into coral protectors. Both coral and the sea-dwelling Bajau people appear to be amphibious beings, moving between a changeable land-water interface, and between different, fluidly interwoven ontological constellations. We show that the failure of conservation organizations to recognize the ontologically ambiguous nature of "coral" and "people" translates to a breakdown of outreach goals. Mobilizing the concept of amphibiousness to engage this ambiguity and fluidity, we describe the moving land-water interface as the actual living environment for both coral and people. The notion of amphibiousness, we suggest, has practical and political value, in particular for reconsidering outreach and how it may be reframed as a process involving ontological dialogue. For conservation outreach to become seaworthy, it needs to cultivate an amphibious capacity, capable of moving in-between and relating partly overflowing ways of knowing and being. Providing room for ambiguity, thinking with amphibiousness furthermore encourages suspension of the (Western) tendency to explain the Other, to fix what does not add up. As such, it is of heuristic relevance for the on-going discussions of ontological multiplicity that have proliferated at the intersection between STS and anthropology.

Leaky bodies: masculinity and risk in the practice of cyanide fishing in Indonesia

“…Indeed, according to a Mandar spirit mediator, the affect of the sea spirits could best be understood as a form of eating. As I have elaborated elsewhere, female sea spirits were known in the region to 'eat' fisher's masculine power and strength -to take something back, when the fisher has been greedy, taking too much fish (Pauwelussen and Verschoor 2017). Here, a political economy of environmental exploitation translates into the entangled and gendered debt relations between humans and spirits (Spyer 1997).…”

New Directions in Maritime and Fisheries Anthropology

“…In a marine multispecies ethnography, Moore (2012) examines the role of lionfish as an introduced species into the Caribbean and how local fishers are responding to the challenges and opportunities that invasive species produce both in natural and socioeconomic contexts. More recently, Pauwelussen and Verschoor (2017) propose an "amphibious" perspective to grasp local understandings of interactions between humans and coral reefs in Indonesia and suggest that this new ontology can better achieve marine conservation outreach goals at the interface of science, technology, and society. In other exciting new research, which brings the sciences and humanities closer together, Hayward (2018) studies the mixed African and European descendants of castaways into Cape Nguni communities in South Africa from the standpoint of their rich marine oral histories and present-day identities.…”

Commentary 11 to the Manifesto for the marine social sciences: culture and religion

“…Moreover, indigenous conceptions of the sea as a social assemblage of beings contrast with the modern idea of the natural and the social as distinct realms (Lowe 2006;Zerner 2003). Such discrepancies affect collaboration in management and conservation outreach (Pauwelussen and Verschoor 2017;Verschuuren et al 2015).…”