Despite the recent advances in the life sciences and the remarkable investment in drug discovery research, the success rate of small-molecule drug development remains low. Safety is the second most influential factor of drug attrition in clinical studies; thus, the selection of compounds with fewer toxicity concerns is crucial to increase the success rate of drug discovery. Compounds that promiscuously bind to multiple targets are likely to cause unexpected pharmacological activity that may lead to adverse effects. Therefore, avoiding such compounds during early research stages would contribute to identifying compounds with a higher chance of success in the clinic. To evaluate the interaction profile against a wide variety of targets, we constructed a small-scale promiscuity panel (PP) consisting of eight targets (ROCK1, PDE4D2, GR, PPARγ, 5-HT 2B , adenosine A 3 , M1, and GABA A ) that were selected from diverse gene families. The validity of this panel was confirmed by comparison with the promiscuity index evaluated from larger-scale panels. Analysis of data from the PP revealed that both lipophilicity and basicity are likely to increase promiscuity, while the molecular weight does not significantly contribute. Additionally, the promiscuity assessed using our PP correlated with the occurrence of both in vitro cytotoxicity and in vivo toxicity, suggesting that the PP is useful to identify compounds with fewer toxicity concerns. In summary, this small-scale and cost-effective PP can contribute to the identification of safer compounds that would lead to a reduction in drug attrition due to safety issues.