“…For example, while 4-6 month-exposures to concentrated PM 2.5 in New York (Chen and Nadziejko 2005 ;Chen et al 2010 ;Sun et al 2005Sun et al , 2008Ying et al 2009 ) yielded positive results, 5-week exposures to concentrated PM 2.5 in Los Angeles only resulted in a non-statistically signifi cant trend for increased atherosclerotic lesions (Araujo et al 2008 ). Further, while the study from Ying et al showed that 4-month inhalation exposures to concentrated PM 2.5 from the Upper East side of Manhattan (6 h/day, 5 days/week) of cholesterol enriched diet (CED)-fed 6-week-old ApoE -/-mice resulted in ~89 % increase in aortic atherosclerotic plaques over controls (Ying et al 2009 ), CED-fed mice that were exposed for 5-6 months to CAPs from Sterling Forest, New York resulted in a 58-68 % increase in atherosclerotic lesions over controls (Sun et al 2005(Sun et al , 2008. As noted by the authors, the larger effects with the Manhattan PM 2.5 could have been due to higher PM 2.5 levels and/or a higher relative content of organic carbon (OC) and elemental carbon (EC) in the Manhattan PM 2.5 (Ying et al 2009 ).…”