Dissolved aluminum (Ill) in acidic soils or culture media is often rhizotoxic (inhibitory to root elongation). Alkaline solutions of Al are also sometimes rhizotoxic, and for that reason toxicity has been attributed to the aluminate ion, AI(OH)4-. In the present study, seedlings of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Tyler) and red clover (Trifolium pratense L. cv Kenland) were cultured in aerated aluminate solutions at pH 8.0 to 8.9. The bulk phases of these solutions were free of reactive polynuclear hydroxy-AI (including the extremely toxic species AlO4Al12 [OH] species (15, 26). That one or more ofthese species is rhizotoxic has been known for many decades (7), but only recently has there been progress in determining the relative toxicities of the various species (4, 8, 12-14, 19, 21, 22). Evidence for the toxicity of a polynuclear Al species has been offered several times (2,21,22, 27), and this species has now been identified as Al13 ' (22). This species is easily prepared in artificial solutions, but upon aging, All3 undergoes a conversion to other Al species that are unreactive with commonly used assay reagents and may comprise microcrystalline gibbsite or other solid-phase Al (3,22). Al,3 is at least 10-fold more rhizotoxic than A13+ (22), and the possibility of its occurrence is a complicating factor in the study ofthe toxicity of other species (13). (14). Perhaps protonation of cell surface sites reduces Al3+ binding. In addition, Al,3 may have accumulated in the root free space as mononuclear hydroxy-Al increased in the bulk media.Al in alkaline fly ash (9, 25), bauxite residue (6), and hydroponic culture media (6) appears to be toxic, and that toxicity has been attributed to aluminate (Al[OH]4) which, according to species computations, would constitute >99% of the mononuclear hydroxy-Al at pH > 7.9. However, these media were complex, and, appropriately, the authors made no attempt to compute the species composition. In addition, no attempt was made to detect Al13, whose toxicity was not widely known at the time of those studies.The present experiments were performed as part of an ongoing investigation of the relative rhizotoxicity of Al species. The major emphasis of the study was to employ simple solutions whose species composition could be computed and to ensure the absence of Al,3 in the bulk phase of the culture media.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Seedling CultureSeedlings of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Tyler) and red clover (Trifolium pratense L. cv Kenland) were cultured at 25°C in aerated, 500-mL solutions as described previously (10, 13). All alkaline solutions were aerated overnight prior to the introduction of seedlings. After 2 d, root lengths were measured and the culture media were assayed for Al by the ferron method to be described. In a typical experiment intended to test the apparent toxicity of aluminate, the culture media were prepared by adding 2.95 mL of 1 M NaHCO3, 0 to 50 mL of a 1 mm stock solution of LiAl02 (in 1 mM NaOH), 50 to 0 mL of a 1 mm stock solution of LiCl (in 1 1...