Alternative framings of transnational waste flows: reflections based on the Egypt–China PET plastic trade

Abstract

Through a discussion of Egypt-China trade in PET plastic, this paper seeks to show how contemporary recycling economies do not all conform to North-South directionalities, nor to the other assumptions about agency, vulnerability and environmental damage that inhere in the 'neo-colonial geographies of inequality' paradigm. In so doing, it seeks to contribute to developing more optimistic and nuanced alternative framings of global waste flows. The paper follows a two-part structure. The first half provides background on the author's research methods, the recycling business in Egypt and its ties to China before further outlining the paradigm the paper seeks to nuance, particularly as it has been developed through and applied to e-waste case studies and entrenched in the principal legal instrument governing transboundary waste flows, the Basel Convention. The second half of the paper, after some conceptual notes outlining and locating the author's approach to the market in the literature, attempts to provide a few details of the Egypt-China PET market from fieldwork, focusing on two price-shaping/making processes: market fluctuations during the global economic crisis in 2008/09 and the quality standards criteria applied by Chinese buyers.

From Waste to Resource: The Trade in Wastes and Global Recycling Economies

“…Indeed, the UN-StEP project indicates that the majority of e-waste now comes from non-OECD countries [RELATED RESOURCE 4]. Harvesting activities therefore are no longer confined to the Global North, and there is not only evidence of networks of Chinese traders in Africa [170] but also of African (Nigerian) traders in China. Further research is required to document emergent research on South-South material flows, to establish how enhanced competition affects trader activities, and how firms supplying them respond to increased competition for their scrap.…”

Recycling in Brasil: Paper and Plastic Supply Chain

“…A continental sized country such as Brasil has great regional variation in terms of recyclable material prices, which are all linked to commodity prices and to global market variation, as is the case all over the world [35]. On the other hand, Brasilian recyclable material is mainly utilized in the inner market and there is a lack of information and understanding about how the international recycling market works and how to participate in it.…”

Centering the Korle Lagoon: exploring blue political ecologies of E-Waste in Ghana

“…Unlike flows of e-waste found in the Global North, waste arriving in Accra (and in the majority of the Global South) are generally sourced internationally (Grant 2006(Grant , 2016 Grant and Oteng-Ababio 2012), a reality that helps explain why and how the information technology (IT) revolution is changing established global e-waste trade dynamics. For example, instead of only the U.S., Canada, and countries in Europe, now China, India, and South Africa are emerging as dominant producers, sources, and destinations for electronic discard (Breivik et al 2014;Furniss 2015;Lepawsky 2014;.…”