Alternate Research Paradigms

Abstract

This article reviews the major paradigms that are different from the positivistic research tradition of reductive experimentation and presents an approach to teaching these paradigms in graduate counseling psychology programs. Arguments and issues related to broadening reductive-positivist conceptions of research are first summarized. Three alternate paradigms, (a) the naturalistic-ethnographic, (b) the phenomenological, and (c) the cybernetic, as well as other high-context approaches are described. Each paradigm is presented in terms of its conceptual base, methodological characteristics, applications, types of research questions it can address, and its strengths and limitations. A curriculum for teaching these alternate paradigms as an extension of standard research courses is proposed. The teaching philosophy, teaching-learning mechanisms, instructional resources, and observations from past experiences of implementation are given. It is argued that such teaching would promote students 'epistemic development and more informed method choices, as well as facilitate the integration of theory, research, and practice.

Navajo Nation Brain Drain: An Exploration of Returning College Graduates’ Perspectives

“…The summaries of each interview were read to determine existing patterns. This process is referred to as the hermeneutic circle, and has been described as a spiral or reflexive process through which investigators seek to uncover progressively deeper levels of meaning in a text (Hoshmand, 1989;Kvale & Brinkmann, 2009;Polkinghorne, 1984).…”

Mentoring Person-Centered Spiritual Maturation

“…When conceptual saturation is reached, categories are organized into constructs for higher-order theoretical and numerical analysis. Grounded Theory is particularly useful for studying dynamics of change (Chamberlain, 1999; Strauss & Corbin, 1998) because it employs a phenomenological perspective that examines the lived experience of participants (Hoshmand, 1989; Polkinghorne, 1983). Students’ self-inquiry essays provided written documentation for close textual analysis of learning processes (Polkinghorne, 1988).…”

Understanding Change in Romantic Relationship Expectations of International Female Students from Turkey

“…In addition to the interviews, research notes taken during the interviews also were included in the data analysis. As Hoshmand (1989) indicates, data analysis in qualitative research involves a cyclical descriptive process of categorization, coding, and recoding of data with the aim of achieving an internal order by identifying themes, categories, and subcategories. Accordingly, in analyzing our data, we used open, axial, and selective coding (Strauss and Corbin 1998).…”