Altered Images: Understanding the Influence of Unrealistic Images and Beauty Aspirations

Abstract

In this paper we consider the impact of digitally altered images on individuals’ body satisfaction and beauty aspirations. Drawing on current psychological literature we consider interventions designed to increase knowledge about the ubiquity and unreality of digital images and, in the form of labelling, provide information to the consumer. Such interventions are intended to address the negative consequences of unrealistic beauty ideals. However, contrary to expectations, such initiatives may not be effective, especially in the long-term, and may even be counter-productive. We seek to understand this phenomenon of our continued aspiration for beauty ideals we know to be unreal and even impossible. We draw on our respective disciplines to offer psychological and philosophical accounts for why this might be. We conclude that beauty ideals are deeply embedded in our aspirations, practices, and in our constructions of ourselves. Given this, it is not surprising that simply increasing knowledge, or providing information, will be insufficient to challenge them.

Why students do not turn on their video cameras during online classes and an equitable and inclusive plan to encourage them to do so

“…It may be also helpful to tell them that a common tip from people whose careers involve working from home is to maintain a routine that often includes getting dressed and good personal hygiene (Knowlton, 2020; Limón, 2020; Rivkind, 2012). We should also note that the Zoom program currently offers a feature to “Touch up my appearance,” which airbrushes a user's face in real time, although we do not promote its use as we suspect it contributes to the negative effects of unrealistic beauty ideals despite being an obvious manipulation (MacCallum & Widdows, 2018).…”

Using Retouch-Free Disclaimers in Advertisements to Reduce Negative Social Comparison in Adolescents

“…However, there is evidence that disclaimers may not have any impact on how people perceive retouched images. In fact, being aware of retouching on an image of a model can actually increase the perceived attractiveness of the model to viewers (Harrison & Hefner, 2014) or increase the occurrence of negative thoughts (Selimbegovic & Chatard, 2015;MacCallum & Widdows, 2018), creating the opposite of the intended effect. This could have been because the mere mention of retouching primed subjects to think about physical appearance, and thus their own perceived attractiveness.…”

Understanding body image perception and body image discontentment in early adolescence

“…(18,19) Such frustrations observed among adolescent girls are suggestive of physiological changes taking place as the girls are undergoing pubertal changes and are moving away from thin-ideal body types. (20) Girls were also leading in the use of beauty apps to correct body shape and appearance of their images and photographs. These results are in line with a study in which adolescent girls showing social comparison tendencies were using manipulated and enhanced images on social media.…”