‘Alexa, I feel for you!’ Observers’ Empathetic Reactions towards a Conversational Agent

Abstract

Conversational agents and smart speakers have grown in popularity offering a variety of options for use, which are available through intuitive speech operation. In contrast to the standard dyad of a single user and a device, voice-controlled operations can be observed by further attendees resulting in new, more social usage scenarios. Referring to the concept of ‘media equation’ and to research on the idea of ‘computers as social actors,’ which describes the potential of technology to trigger emotional reactions in users, this paper asks for the capacity of smart speakers to elicit empathy in observers of interactions. In a 2 × 2 online experiment, 140 participants watched a video of a man talking to an Amazon Echo either rudely or neutrally (factor 1), addressing it as ‘Alexa’ or ‘Computer’ (factor 2). Controlling for participants’ trait empathy, the rude treatment results in participants’ significantly higher ratings of empathy with the device, compared to the neutral treatment. The form of address had no significant effect. Results were independent of the participants’ gender and usage experience indicating a rather universal effect, which confirms the basic idea of the media equation. Implications for users, developers and researchers were discussed in the light of (future) omnipresent voice-based technology interaction scenarios.

Understanding Public Perceptions of AI Conversational Agents: A Cross-Cultural Analysis

“…This preference among Chinese users aligns with their cultural inclination to anthropomorphize technology [21,38]. Verbal communication encompasses more than mere words; it includes rich, human-like nuances and emotional cues, making these interfaces feel warmer [10,24,71]. Previous HCI studies have shown that text communication is often seen as less natural and warm compared to oral communication [78], which can lead to a reduced sense of anthropomorphism.…”

Shopping with Voice Assistants: How Empathy Affects Individual and Family Decision-Making Outcomes

“…This initial step towards autonomous shopping has the potential to significantly reduce (or even eliminate) the need for human decision-making (de Bellis & Johar, 2020). Social and relational capabilities in VAs may further increase their influence on consumer behavior contributions to such trends (Canziani & MacSween, 2021;Carolus et al, 2021).…”

“…We demonstrate that research on human-VA interaction that ignores the effect of empathy and its social-emotional determinants on future behavioral intentions is likely to generate biased results. The study of humans' empathetic reactions toward social bots mainly aims at developing better empathic agents (Carolus et al, 2021). Following a different approach, this research simulates an agent's empathic behavior to foster a consumer's affective response towards that empathic agent (von der Pütten et al, 2020).…”

“Imagine this smart speaker to have a body”: An analysis of the external appearances and the characteristics that people associate with voice assistants

“…Similarly, virtual agents and social robots were shown to elicit social responses (for an overview: Krämer et al, 2015). Studies focused on intelligent voice assistants as devices added the new feature of speech to CASA research (Carolus et al, 2021). Although there were early attempts to analyze the effects of "talking devices" (Nass et al, 1997), implementation of the speech functions was rather poor (desktop computers "talking" with pre-recorded human voices) and of low external validity as devices used at that time simply did not have these features.…”