Alarming levels of stigma toward generalized dystonia: A cross-cultural comparison

Abstract

Introduction Although stigma has been linked to poor quality of life, studies examining its prevalence in dystonia are lacking. Our objective was to determine prevalence and predictors of stigma against generalized dystonia in diverse cultural settings. Method Participants were 273 (65.9% female) patients and visitors approached at primary care clinics from three populations: León, Nicaragua (92 participants); a mostly-Hispanic Clinic in Omaha, NE USA (85 participants); and a mostly-non-Hispanic population in Omaha, Nebraska (96 participants). Participants learned about generalized dystonia, epilepsy and schizophrenia through reading a small vignette and viewing videos, followed by a questionnaire designed to identify stigma. We compared levels of stigma between dystonia and other conditions at different sites and measured variables that could affect them. Results Prevalence of stigma was high toward dystonia (33.00%), similar to epilepsy and lower than schizophrenia. The results showed a complex relationship between the studied variables and level of stigma, especially with age. Female gender predicted more stigmatizing answers. Country of origin, level of education and self-identification of Hispanic ethnicity did not affect stigma. Learning more personal information about the dystonia patient decreased dystonia, a proof that unjustified preliminary negative judgment was present. Conclusions Stigma against generalized dystonia was very prevalent across all the communities studied. Demographic and socio-cultural variables had different correlations to level of stigma, underlying the complexity of this problem. The alarming levels of stigma against dystonia justify further studies on how to minimize its impact on our patients.

Mental health and quality of life in patients with craniofacial movement disorders: A cross-sectional study

“…Hemifacial spasm (HFS) and Meige syndrome are two common types of craniofacial movement disorders characterized by intermittent twitching of facial muscles ( 1 , 2 ), which may lead to inconvenience and are associated with a mental burden. Although motor symptoms may be alleviated by clinical treatment, patients with craniofacial movement disorders experience psychological stressors, such as depression and stigma ( 3 , 4 ). Furthermore, the disease-related quality of life (QoL), which affects subsequent management, is generally underestimated ( 5 ).…”

Transitional Care for Young People with Movement Disorders: Consensus‐Based Recommendations from the MDS Task Force on Pediatrics

“…We suggest focusing on motor disability and psychiatric comorbidities, which are frequently encountered in this context. Likewise, the level of perceived stigmatization and body image concerns should be investigated as they likely represent a significant determinant of quality of life in young people with visible movement disorders 28 . (2) The influence of transitional care programs on population health and individuals is difficult to evaluate because we need validated tools to measure it and a definition of successful transition in movement disorders.…”

Psychological Traits and Behavioural Influences in Patients with Dystonia—An Observational Cohort Study in a Romanian Neurology Department

“…Possible explanations reside from the effect of the disease itself on patients’ productivity and stigmatization. According to a cross-cultural comparison study, patients with generalized dystonia are subjected to a relatively high percentage of stigma (33%) [ 29 ], which leads to increased psychological distress, poorer health outcomes [ 30 ], and negative attitudes toward work [ 31 ].…”