Neurotransmitter:sodium symporters (NSS) in the SLC6 family terminate neurotransmission by coupling the thermodynamically favorable transport of ions to the thermodynamically unfavorable transport of neurotransmitter back into presynaptic neurons. While a combination of structural, functional, and computational studies on LeuT, a bacterial NSS homolog, has provided critical insight into the mechanism of sodium-coupled transport, the mechanism underlying substrate-specific transport rates is still not understood. We present a combination of MD simulations, single-molecule FRET imaging, and measurements of Na + binding and substrate transport that reveal an allosteric mechanism in which residues F259 and I359 in the substrate binding pocket couple substrate binding to Na + release from the Na2 site through allosteric modulation of the stability of a partially-open, inward-facing state. We propose a new model for transport selectivity in which the two residues act as a volumetric sensor that inhibits the transport of bulky amino acids. Kirschstein National Research Service Award F31 DA035533 to M.V.L. Computational results utilized in this work were carried out at resources of the Oak Ridge Leadership