AI Recommendation Service Acceptance: Assessing the Effects of Perceived Empathy and Need for Cognition

Abstract

This study investigated the effect of perceived technology quality and personalization quality on behavioral intentions, mediated by perceived empathy in using an artificial intelligence (AI) recommendation service. The study was based on a theoretical model of artificial intelligent device use acceptance. We also tested the moderating effect of individuals’ need for cognition, influencing empathy. Data collection was conducted through an online survey using a nationally recognized consumer research panel service in Korea. The participants were asked to respond to their preferences and needs on sneakers; then, they randomly experienced the AI (versus human expert) recommendation service that offers a recommended product. A total of 200 data were analyzed using SPSS 21.0 for descriptive statistics, reliability analysis, and PROCESS analysis, and AMOS 21.0 for confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation modeling (SEM). Results revealed that, compared with the human (expert) recommendation service, the AI recommendation service increased perceived technology quality, which increased personalization quality. Technology and personalization quality had a positive influence on behavioral intentions, mediated by perceived empathy. In addition, when individuals had a high level of need for cognition, the effect of personalization quality on empathy was stronger. However, individuals with a low level of need for cognition perceived greater empathy, as technology quality increased. The findings of the current study improve understanding of how consumers accept AI technology-driven services in the online shopping context.

Analyzing Determinants for Adoption of Intelligent Personal Assistant: An Empirical Study

“…Consumption values also make different contributions to the customer behaviors. Functional value represents the perceived utility and performance of the provided product or service, formed through its functional, utilitarian, or physical attributes [12]. Social value is defined as the acceptability at the specific level where there is consistency among the perceived product or service, individual social status, and the social environment.…”

“…At present, there are around 43 million devices installed with IPA from leading vendors of Chinese origin, such as Baidu and iFlytek, and this number will rise to 1.2 billion in 2021 [9,10]. Today, when people think of IPAs, it is clear how much artificial intelligence (AI) can help human beings: by navigating the fastest route based on the current traffic conditions, providing the weather forecast for the following days, suggesting songs from KKBox or Spotify, recommending a shopping list based on the purchasing history, and even the next travel destination can be suggested [11,12]. All of these can be achieved by the powerful artificial intelligence (AI) system through the user experience of intelligent personal assistants (IPAs) around us: conversational, personalized, and contextual.…”

Applying Importance–Satisfaction Model to Evaluate Customer Satisfaction: An Empirical Study of Foodpanda

“…This study explored 12 service elements obtained from previous studies [2,33] and in-depth discussion of experts and customer s to evaluate the user satisfaction towards Foodpanda. The 12 elements were the number of vendors (1), food style (2), attitude of the delivery staff (3), delivery speed (4), appearance of the delivery staff (5), food freshness (6), food price (7), user-friendliness of the app (8), delivery price (9), vendor awareness (10), celebrity en- Importance and satisfaction variables on service elements are two indicators applied to evaluate the corresponding service quality performance. Therefore, scholars have developed the Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) [14] and Importance-Satisfaction Model [13] to improve disadvantage of service quality.…”

“…This study explored 12 service elements obtained from previous studies [2,33] and in-depth discussion of experts and customer s to evaluate the user satisfaction towards Foodpanda. The 12 elements were the number of vendors (1), food style (2), attitude of the delivery staff (3), delivery speed (4), appearance of the delivery staff (5), food freshness (6), food price (7), user-friendliness of the app (8), delivery price (9), vendor awareness (10), celebrity endorsement (11) and sales promotions (12). We divided the questionnaire into two partsimportance and satisfaction-and adopted a five-point Likert scale to measure the attitudes and opinions of the respondents.…”

“…In the service literature, empathy is regarded as one of the five dimensions measuring service quality [9,10], which refers to a customer's evaluation of reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and service quality [11]. However, when it comes to a business's competitive advantage, customer satisfaction, the difference between the customer's expectation and experience, needs to be examined because satisfied customers are loyal and an increase the frequency of repurchases helps create new customers by word of mouth marketing [12].…”