Agreement among Readers on What is Relevant in Self-Help Psychology Books

Abstract

It was hypothesized that text marking in self-help psychology books would indicate that readers agree on which pages and lines contain relevant information. Previously owned copies of two self-help book titles (n=48, n=38), all with marked text, were collected from second-hand book stores and scored for line and page marking. Chi-squares for goodness-of-fit yielded significant differences between observed and chance agreement in marking behavior. Intraclass and KR-20 correlations were significantly different from zero, suggesting that readers agreed on what information was relevant and irrelevant. Actual users of self-help books may have similar standards because of cultural values, social group relations, or common problem experiences.

A Tendency to Essentialism? Discourses about Women’s Leadership

“…As we can see, the predominating terms used in these books include self, internal, mindful, feelings, emotions, etc. These are concepts that focus on each reader seeking their fears and hopes from within him/herself (Forest 1997;Forest et al 2003;Papalini 2016), and relating them with the obstacles and problems that they have had to face in their working lives. This discourse is fed with the language of psychology and, to a great extent, it takes us to what Eva Illouz (2007Illouz ( , 2010 calls "emotional capitalism"-referring to the commercialization of emotions used to serve the neoliberal system.…”

Género y management en el marco neoliberal. Un análisis crítico para la emergencia de liderazgos feministas

“…Como se puede observar, los términos predominantes en estos textos son self, internal, mindful, feelings, emotions… Se trata de conceptos que se centran en explorar el interior de cada lector/a, sus miedos y aspiraciones (Forest 1997;Forest, Del Ben, y Toews 2003), y relacionarlos con los obstáculos y problemas a los que han tenido que hacer frente durante su vida laboral. Este discurso se nutre del lenguaje de la psicología y nos remite en gran medida a lo que Eva Illouz dio en llamar capialismo emocional, y que ya hemos tratado anteriorrmente.…”