Chicken erythrocyte chromatin, obtained after fragmentation with micrococcal nuclease, appears to remain folded in a stable distribution of supranucleosomal structures in buffers containing 80 mM NaC1. These supranucleosomal particles are composed of on average 25 nucleosomes. However, the integrity of the linker DNA within these particles is not required. The supranucleosomal particles have been interpreted by others as superbeads cut out of a preexisting granular nominal 30-nm chromatin fibre. We show that the same distribution of supranucleosomal structures (even those containing internal DNA scissions) can be reconstituted from unfolded nuclear chromatin extracts as present in 10 mM or 600 mM NaCl. Moreover, fractions of oligonucleosomes with mean lengths between 6 and 15 nucleosomes reassemble or aggregate into a limit series of multimeric species. The existence of an assembly barrier could be inferred as we were unable to observe a stable and soluble assembly product containing more than about 25 nucleosomes. We propose an alternative explanation for the generation and observation of a constant distribution of supranucleosomal structures in nuclear extracts, based on the assembly or aggregation property of oligonucleosomes and on the existence of an assembly barrier.The knowledge of the interphase chromatin structure, the nominal 30-nm fibre, is still in a very primordial and even controversial stage. Based on electron microscopic observations, two main categories of nucleosome packaging modes have been proposed : (a) uniform packaging of nucleosomes into a continuous solenoid [l, 21 and (b) [14, 151 or chromatin [12] with micrococcal nuclease or Ca2 +/Mg2 +-dependent endonuclease led to the production of discrete higher-order chromatin structures. These higher-order chromatin structures were revealed upon sucrose gradient sedimentation at near physiological ionic strengths as a broad, fast-sedimenting peak persistently migrating to the same position, independent of the extent of the DNA degradation. Although the linker DNA within the fast-sedimenting higher-order chromatin structures contained double-strand DNA cuts, these particles appeared to be resistant against unfolding.The number of nucleosomes constituting the fast-sedimenting particles is in close agreement with the number of nucleosomes estimated to be present within the proposed superbeads observed by electron microscopy [15 -171. It is
51.Correspondence to S. Muyldermans, Algemene Biologie, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Paardenstraat 65, B-1640 Sint Genesius Rode, BelgiumAbbreviations. bp, base pairs; kb, lo3 base pairs.Enzymes. Micrococcal nuclease (EC 3.1.31 .I).tempting to conclude that the discrete higher-order chromatin structures, revealed in sucrose gradient analysis, are the isolated particles (superbeads) originating from a preexisting periodically stabilized 30-nm chromatin fibre [ l l -151. One must, however, be careful when considering the in vitro observation of these supranucleosomal particles as representative for the chromatin...