Agency and Change in Healthcare Organizations: Workers’ Attempts to Navigate Multiple Logics in Hospice Care

Abstract

There is no doubt that the organization of healthcare is currently shifting, partly in response to changing macrolevel policies. Studies of healthcare policies often do not consider healthcare workers' experiences of policy change, thus limiting our understanding of when and how policies work. This article uses longitudinal qualitative data, including participant observation and semistructured interviews with workers within hospice care as their organizations shifted in response to a Medicare policy change. Prior to the policy change, I find that the main innovation of hospice-the interdisciplinary team-is able to resist logics from the larger medical institution. However, when organizational pressures increase, managers and workers adjust in ways that reinforce medical logics and undermine the interdisciplinary team. These practices illustrate processes by which rationalization of healthcare affects workers' experiences and the type of care available to patients.

When People Facing Dementia Choose to Hasten Death: The Landscape of Current Ethical, Legal, Medical, and Social Considerations in the United States

“…These members of the patient care team bring their own moral, ethical, and legal concerns and cultural perspectives to dementia care, including to proposals that would result in significantly different care plans for some patients with advanced dementia. Research reflecting the perspectives of aides on any topic is extremely limited 26 . In this situation, as in others, the perspectives of professionals with greater power and more limited patient‐care roles should not be substituted for the perspectives of those with day‐to‐day responsibility for patient care.…”

Too Soon or Too Late: Rethinking the Significance of Six Months When Dementia Is a Primary Diagnosis

“…Yet in hospice and other areas of health care ranging from intensive care units and other medical wards to nursing homes to community practice, the cultural narrative of the six‐month rule has become institutionalized as a heuristic—a problem‐solving tool—for marking the period when the end of life starts. Once an idea becomes institutionalized in thinking and practice, thinking outside that idea can feel risky, while staying inside that idea feels normal 5 …”

“…Once an idea becomes institutionalized in thinking and practice, thinking outside that idea can feel risky, while staying inside that idea feels normal. 5 Too Soon or Too Late? Q uestions about if, how, and whether dementia fits into end-of-life choices and provisions in the United States frequently bump up against the six-month rule as an embedded cultural narrative about how to tell when a person is "really" nearing the end of life.…”

Key issues of health and safety for workers in residential aged care: An expert study

“…An example is the care institutional logic which follows a worker's professional values and beliefs. This form of logic may push RAC workers to consider residents' health and safety before their own (50). As competing institutional logics rely upon differing interpretations of reality, their existence may exacerbate solving complex OHS problems (49).…”