Age-Related Impairments in the Revision of Syntactic Misanalyses: Effects of Prosody

Abstract

Two experiments examined whether young and older adults differ in comprehending sentences that contain temporary syntactic closure ambiguities. Experiment 1 examined age-related differences using the Auditory Moving Window (AMW) task, in which sentences were presented in a segment-by-segment self-paced fashion. Experiment 2 examined age-related differences using a sentence recall task, in which sentences were presented in their entirety. Sentences were constructed to have cooperating prosody (i.e., where prosody is consistent with the syntactic boundaries), baseline prosody (i.e., where prosody is ambiguous in the syntactically ambiguous region), and conflicting prosody (i.e., where cross-splicing relocates the prosodic phrase break at a misleading point in syntactic structure). The results showed that both young and older adults make comparable use of prosodic information to interpret temporary syntactic ambiguities, although younger adults may make use of this information more quickly than older adults. In addition, older adults appeared to be less able than young adults to revise initial syntactic misinterpretations caused by conflicting prosodic information. These results are interpreted with respect to age-related impairments in the allocation of working memory resources and inefficient inhibitory function during spoken language processing.

The effects of age on the strategic use of pitch accents in memory for discourse: A processing-resource account.

“…This finding is consistent with other work showing that the influence of prosody on other linguistic processes, such as syntactic processing (Kjelgaard et al, 1999; Titone et al, 2006) and word recognition (Wingfield et al, 2000), also remains well-preserved with age.…”

Segmental and Prosodic Approaches to Accent Management

“…For example, an early seminal work of Miller and Isard (1963) demonstrated improved recall of oral presentation of nonsense words or ungrammatical strings of words if the items were presented with typical sentence prosody rather than simply spoken as a list. More recently, prosody has been shown to be important in processing ambiguous sentences (Joeks, Redeker, & Hendriks, 2009;Titone et al, 2006) and processing of humorous stories and jokes (Wennerstrom, 2011).…”

Narrative Comprehension Abilities of Children with Typical Hearing and Children Using Hearing Aids: A Pilot Study

“…Just as elderly people benefit from select adult-controlled strategies that include reduced cognitive load, slower linguistic input, and intraturn pauses designed to facilitate syntactic analyses (Dagerman, McDonald, & Harm, 2006;Titon et al, 2006), so do children with auditory processing difficulties (Rowe, Pollard, & Rowe, 2005). Phrasal intraturn pauses improve the attention skills of children with auditory processing atypicalities (Rowe et al, 2005).…”