Age-Related Differences in the Uncanny Valley Effect

Abstract

Background: Due to declining birthrates and an increasing aging population, shortage of the caregiving labor force has become a global issue. Among various efforts toward the solution, introducing robotic products for assistance could provide an effective way to help older adults in their daily lives. As previous studies have indicated that older adults' acceptance of robots is lower than that of younger adults, enhancing older adults' acceptance of robots is imperative. Because older adults' first impressions based on a robot's appearance might affect their acceptance of the robot, we investigated the uncanny valley effect (UVE) here. The UVE refers to the phenomenon that people rate robots more positively as robots become more humanlike, but only up to a certain point; as robots approach a near-perfect similarity to human appearance, likeability drops and forms the uncanny valley. Nevertheless, evidence for the UVE came mainly from younger adults. Objective: The present study aimed to examine whether the UVE varies across different age groups and whether a robot's appearance would affect participants' acceptance of the robot's service or companionship. Methods: An online questionnaire study was conducted with 255 participants, including younger (n = 77, age 18-39 years), middle-aged (n = 87, age 40-59 years), and older (n = 91, age 60-87 years) adults. Participants were asked to view each picture in a set selected from a total of 83 robot pictures and evaluate their impressions of each robot and the intention of use regarding robot function as a service provider or a companion. Results: The UVE was found in younger and middle-aged adults; however, older adults did not show the UVE. Older adults preferred humanlike over non-humanlike robots, regardless of robot function. Conclusion: The design of assistive robots should take the UVE into consideration by customizing robot appearance based on the age group of the intended user.

Long-Term Exercise Assistance: Group and One-on-One Interactions between a Social Robot and Seniors

“…The least preferred feature was the lower body as participants preferred to see the robot have legs to engage in leg exercises as well. These findings are consistent with previous studies comparing older age groups' preferences in robots against other groups [76][77][78]. It was consistently found that older adults preferred features that were more human-like as they were more familiar with human appearances.…”

A transdisciplinary review and framework of consumer interactions with embodied social robots: Design, delegate, and deploy

“…Studies that focused on hardware design suggest that consumers prefer humanoid social robots over zoomorphic‐ and machine‐like robots (e.g., Belanche et al., 2020; Chu et al., 2019; Tu et al., 2020; Walters et al., 2008). A potential explanation for this preference might be that an embodied, humanoid robot increases consumers’ mind perceptions and positive personality attributions (e.g., Broadbent et al., 2013).…”

Bridging social marketing and technology in the disability field: an empirical study on the role of cybernetic avatar and social inclusion

“…Thus, it is uncertain if the non-humanlike interfaces paired with a real human voice will be favored equally compared to a human-like interface paired with a robotic voice. Prior studies found that the uncanny valley effect positively impacts consumers' outcome behaviors, including the intention to use a robot (Tu et al, 2020) and the intention to engage with the bot (Moriuchi, 2021). Tu et al (2020) found that users preferred human-like robots over nonhumanlike robots, regardless of their robot function.…”

“…Prior studies found that the uncanny valley effect positively impacts consumers' outcome behaviors, including the intention to use a robot (Tu et al, 2020) and the intention to engage with the bot (Moriuchi, 2021). Tu et al (2020) found that users preferred human-like robots over nonhumanlike robots, regardless of their robot function. In a different context, Moriuchi (2022) found that anthropomorphism positively impacts patients' self-disclosure.…”