Age-period-cohort effects in half a century of motor vehicle theft in the United States

Abstract

Adopting and refining O’Brien’s S-constraint approach, we estimate age-period-cohort effects for motor vehicle theft offences in the United States for over half a century from 1960. Taking the well-established late-teen peak offending age as given, we find period effects reducing theft in the 1970 s, and period, but particularly cohort effects, reducing crime from the 1990s onwards. We interpret these effects as consistent with variation in the prevailing level of crime opportunities, particularly the ease with which vehicles could be stolen. We interpret the post-1990s cohort effect as triggered by a period effect that operated differentially by age: improved vehicle security reduced juvenile offending dramatically, to the extent that cohorts experienced reduced offending across the life-course. This suggests the prevailing level of crime opportunities in juvenile years is an important determinant of rates of onset and continuance in offending in birth cohorts. We outline additional implications for research and practice.

Security and International Crime Drops

“…This is the pattern that would be expected if the security devices made cars difficult but not impossible to steal, where younger, more inexperienced thieves targeted easier-to-take cars that would provide them and their friends with fun (Farrell et al 2011a). A study of US motor vehicle thefts finds, similarly, that the size of subsequent cohorts of offenders was reduced following the introduction of vehicle security improvements (Dixon and Farrell 2020). The debut crime hypothesis is an important correction to the notion that criminality is simply a function of poor parenting, dysfunctional communities, genetic abnormalities, the underclass, or some form of social malaise.…”

El robo de autos en Reynosa: análisis espacial desde la teoría de las actividades rutinarias y del patrón del crimen

“…Saudita (Alotaibi et al, 2017), indican hallazgos en el mismo sentido. Se argumenta que este grupo de población es más propenso a este crimen debido a su capacidad física, estilos de vida y factores ambientales, lo que permite y/o alienta la comisión de este delito (Dixon y Farrell, 2020).…”

Crime drop in Ghana? Some insights from crime patterns and trends

“…Braga and Weisburd (2020) also found support for the hypothesis that Place-based POP strategies reduced crime. Furthermore, a growing body of empirical studies has emerged concerning the role of period and cohort effects in the decline of crime (Dixon and Farrell 2020;Griffiths and Norris 2020;Kim et al 2016;Lu and Luo 2020;O'Brien 2019;O'Brien and Stockard 2009). For example, Kim et al (2016) found that cohort effects rather than period effects seemed to be a more important predictor in the decline of age-specific felony arrest rates in New York State.…”