Again, making Tanzania great: Magufuli’s restorationist developmental nationalism

Abstract

This article is about how ideologies legitimize authoritarianism. The literature argues that liberation nationalists discursively construct "liberation" as an ongoing struggle and justify their authoritarian rule until its completion. By recurrently postponing liberation, they extend this justification of authoritarianism. Nonetheless, their claim that the nation is part-way through liberation becomes less plausible over time. Liberation nationalism shares a discursive structure with a parallel class of developmental nationalisms. I analyze the ideology of President Magufuli and CCM in Tanzania. Instead of claiming that the nation is mid-transformation, they constructed the status quo as a corrupt deviation from a past order: "Nyerere's Tanzania". They conceived of this past order as a nation dedicated to industrial development which would lead to a transformed future. They advocated rupture with the present, the restoration of the past and the resumption of this transformative journey. Restorationism relieves liberation and developmental nationalisms of the rising rhetorical challenge of claiming that the nation has been on a transformative path since liberation. Therefore, Magufuli and CCM developed a variant upon liberation and developmental nationalisms, which also justifies authoritarianism. Unlike them, it remains rhetorically viable as the moment of liberation or development becomes distant. I call it restorationist developmental nationalism.

Tanzania: The Authoritarian Landslide

“…All these things were presented as icons of national development. 9 The ruling party's 2020 campaign celebrated these achievements. The party's message was that it had delivered, but had more to do.…”

The work of class: Cash transfers and community development in Tanzania

“…Receiving benefits without participation is antithetical to this moral economy of development, hence government's strong preference for conditional elements within program design and the inclusion of public works with a rhetorical emphasis on productive activities (Jacob and Pedersen 2018; Myamba and Ulriksen 2016; Ulriksen 2020). The then president of Tanzania, Dr. John Pombe Magufuli, elected in 2015, was committed to reviving the productivist ethic of Tanzanian socialism (Lal 2012) in a policy approach predicated on personal and national self‐reliance through working (Paget 2020). In an intentional evocation of the “Uhuru na kazi” (Freedom and Work) slogan of Julius Nyerere's postindependence nation building, the strapline of Magufuli's first‐term government (2015–20) was “Hapa Kazi Tu!” (Just Work Here!)…”

Repenser la nation à partir du musée ? Le musée Julius Kambarage Nyerere en Tanzanie

“…Ainsi, la dénonciation de la démoralisation de la vie politique que l'on trouve dans les livres d'or n'est pas un effet de la visite : c'est bien plus la visite qui active des répertoires de contestation politique en circulation dans l'espace public -montrant que le musée est une caisse de résonance de dynamiques situées hors de lui. Ces répertoires de la contestation par lesquels Nyerere en est venu à constituer un étalon de mesure de la vertu politique ont été constitués par itérations constantes entre les protestations populaires contre l'immoralité des dirigeants d'aujourd'hui et les promesses des hommes politiques de marcher dans les pas du Mwalimu (Fouéré, 2015 ;Paget, 2020). Ironiquement, le tombeau, le musée Nyerere sont devenus des passages obligés pour les hommes politiques qui promettent d'être à la hauteur de l'incorruptibilité dont Nyerere fit preuve de son vivant (photo 3).…”