“…We interpreted the Valley of Colors Formation as a breccia that formed on the slopes of the Theban cliffs (see above). Said (1981Said ( , 1990 The youngest pluvials (< ~260 Ka) in Egypt are now well dated (Nicholson and Flohn, 1980;Brookes, 1993;Wendorf et al, 1993;Szabo et al, 1995;Crombie et al, 1997;Sultan et al, 1997;Churcher et al, 1999;Hamdan, 2000;Hoelzman et al, 2000;Nicoll, 2001;Smith et al, 2004;Kliendienst et al, 2006;Kieniewicz and Smith, 2007), but uncertainty remains as to the age of the older pluvials.…”