Affective Politics, Debility and Hearing Voices: Towards a Feminist Politics of Ordinary Suffering

Abstract

This paper explores the experiences of women who "hear voices" (auditory verbal hallucinations). We begin by examining historical understandings of women hearing voices, showing these have been driven by androcentric theories of how women's bodies functioned leading to women being viewed as requiring their voices be interpreted by men. We show the twentieth century was associated with recognition that the mental violation of women's minds (represented by some voice-hearing) was often a consequence of the physical violation of women's bodies. We next report the results of a qualitative study into voice-hearing women's experiences (n = 8). This found similarities between women's relationships with their voices and their relationships with others and the wider social context. Finally, we present results from a quantitative study comparing voice-hearing in women (n = 65) and men (n = 132) in a psychiatric setting. Women were more likely than men to have certain forms of voice-hearing (voices conversing) and to have antecedent events of trauma, physical illness, and relationship problems. Voices identified as female may have more positive affect than male voices. We conclude that women voice-hearers have and continue to face specific challenges necessitating research and activism, and hope this paper will act as a stimulus to such work.

Hearing the Unheard: An Interdisciplinary, Mixed Methodology Study of Women’s Experiences of Hearing Voices (Auditory Verbal Hallucinations)

“…( 104 ), p. 1]. This attempts to avoid trauma being experienced as individualized shame, psychopathology and misery, and to instead situate it within a larger context ( 105 ). As Cvetkovich argues, “trauma forges overt connections between politics and emotion” [Ref.…”

Imagining Disability Futurities

“…Such embodied stories of aging with episodic disability have been historically absent from disability‐rights movements, and can go awry in some feminist, queer, and critical disability studies' affirmative framings of disability as post‐human possibility. Carolyn's story speaks against any totalizing teleology of crip temporalities as well as to the silenced politics of what Lisa Blackman calls “ordinary suffering” (Blackman , 25). It is uncomfortable—but encourages important questions.…”

Social Media Sad Girls and the Normalization of Sad States of Being

“…The sad girls share snippets of their lives, expressed in textual or visual forms, which are then reblogged and re-circulated to users beyond the original poster's network. Blackman (2015), also theorizes distributed forms of perception in terms of Grace M. Cho's (2008) notion of a "collective psychic apparatus" (p.156). Perhaps the sad girls' emergence on social CAPACIOUS media can be conceptualized as a development of a collective psychic apparatus, through distributed forms of perception.…”

“…Through distributed forms of perception and meme-like spreading of multiple voices, the phenomenon of the sad girl can be said to manifest an alternative collective psyche (as discussed by Blackman 2015 andCho 2008). By forming a discourse where multiple voices and experiences of living with mental illness get to be heard, an alternative and multifaceted way of conceptualizing sadness becomes available.…”