Adverse outcomes after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy: a study of 700 000 procedures in the national Hospital Episode Statistics database for England

Abstract

SummaryBackgroundArthroscopic partial meniscectomy is one of the most common orthopaedic procedures worldwide. Clinical trial evidence published in the past 6 years, however, has raised questions about the effectiveness of the procedure in some patient groups. In view of concerns about potential overuse, we aimed to establish the true risk of serious complications after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy.MethodsWe analysed national Hospital Episode Statistics data for all arthroscopic partial meniscectomies done in England between April 1, 1997, and March 31, 2017. Simultaneous or staged (within 6 months) bilateral cases were excluded. We identified complications occurring in the 90 days after the index procedure. The primary outcome was the occurrence of at least one serious complication within 90 days, which was defined as either myocardial infarction, stroke, pulmonary embolism, infection requiring surgery, fasciotomy, neurovascular injury, or death. Logistic regression modelling was used to identify factors associated with complications and, when possible, risk was compared with general population data.FindingsDuring the study period 1 088 782 arthroscopic partial meniscectomies were done, 699 965 of which were eligible for analysis. Within 90 days, serious complications occurred in 2218 (0·317% [95% CI 0·304–0·330]) cases, including 546 pulmonary embolisms (0·078% [95% CI 0·072–0·085]) and 944 infections necessitating further surgery (0·135% [95% CI 0·126–0·144]). Increasing age (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 1·247 per decade [95% CI 1·208–1·288) and modified Charlson comorbidity index (adjusted OR 1·860 per 10 units [95% CI 1·708–2·042]) were associated with an increased risk of serious complications. Female sex was associated with a reduced risk of serious complications (adjusted OR 0·640 [95% CI 0·580–0·705). The risk of mortality fell over time (adjusted OR 0·965 per year [95% CI 0·937–0·994]). Mortality, myocardial infarction, and stroke occurred less frequently in the study cohort than in the general population. The risks of infection and pulmonary embolism did not change during the study, and were significantly higher in the study cohort than in the general population. For every 1390 (95% CI 1272–1532) fewer knee arthroscopies done, one pulmonary embolism could be prevented. For every 749 (95% CI 704–801) fewer procedures done, one native knee joint infection could be prevented.InterpretationOverall, the risk associated with undergoing arthroscopic partial meniscectomy was low. However, some rare but serious complications (including pulmonary embolism and infection) are associated with the procedure, and the risks have not fallen with time. In view of uncertainty about the effectiveness of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, an appreciation of relative risks is crucial for patients and clinicians. Our data provide a basis for decision making and consent.FundingUK National Institute for Health Research.

Mortality and adverse joint outcomes following septic arthritis of the native knee: a longitudinal cohort study of patients receiving arthroscopic washout

“…28 The largest age group in our study cohort was the 60-79-year age group and the 90-day mortality in the primary septic arthritis cohort in this age group was 7.39%, in comparison to 0.061% in the same period of time following arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, and 0.233% for the general population. 25 A diagnosis of osteoarthritis was also found to be associated with mortality in our cohort. In the unadjusted model, osteoarthritis was associated with increased odds of mortality, as has been previously observed for all cause and disease specific longer term mortality rates in other cohorts.…”

“…A similar reduction in mortality over time has been observed for patients undergoing elective orthopaedic procedures. 24,25 In the present cohort, the fall in mortality may reflect a similar general improvement in healthcare, and outcomes could also have been influenced, in part, by initiatives such as the international "Surviving Sepsis" campaign and guidelines first published in 2004. 26,27 Older age and pre-existing joint disease have previously been shown to be poor prognostic factors for both joint outcome, mortality, and quality of life after an episode of septic arthritis in a small series of patients.…”

Trends in knee magnetic resonance imaging, arthroscopies and joint replacements in older Australians: still too much low‐value care?

“…Many (or even most) of the MRI tests and arthroscopies identified in our study may have been unnecessary. Although short term adverse events after knee arthroscopy are relatively rare, they may be serious and include venous thromboembolism (approximately five per 1000 procedures), infection (two per 1000 procedures) nerve damage (one per 1000) and death (<1 per 1000) . Longer‐term adverse effects may result from structural damage to the knee, with several studies based upon administrative data suggesting that arthroscopy in older adults may result in earlier need for knee joint replacement…”

What’s new in VTE risk and prevention in orthopedic surgery

“…Based on data from a number of large, population‐based studies, the occurrence of VTE after knee arthroscopy is infrequent (<0.5%) for most patients. A recent UK National Health Service study of severe adverse outcomes of arthroscopic surgery in 700 000 patients described a 0.08% rate of any PE and a 0.001% rate of fatal PE within 90 days . A Kaiser Permanente study of more than 20 000 patients undergoing knee arthroscopy described a 0.25% rate of DVT and a 0.17% rate of PE .…”

“…Service study of severe adverse outcomes of arthroscopic surgery in 700 000 patients described a 0.08% rate of any PE and a 0.001% rate of fatal PE within 90 days. 27 A Kaiser Permanente study of more than 20 000 patients undergoing knee arthroscopy described a 0.25% rate of DVT and a 0.17% rate of PE. 28 An American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program study (N = 12 271) found DVT rates of 0.46% and PE rates of 0.05% within 30 days after knee arthroscopy, 29 and a Mayo Clinic Olmsted County study (N = 4833)…”