Advances in Offender Profiling: A Systematic Review of the Profiling Literature Published Over the Past Three Decades

Abstract

Despite the immense popularity of offender profiling as both a topic of fascination for the general public as well as an academic field of study, concerns have been raised about the development of this area of scientific inquiry. The present study provides a preliminary step towards moving the field forward as it reviews the type and quality of studies dealing with offender profiling over the past 31 years. Based on a content analysis of 132 published articles, the review indicates that researchers investigating this phenomenon rarely publish multiple articles, and they are generally reported across many different journals, thereby making knowledge synthesis and knowledge transfer problematic. In addition, the majority of papers published in the area are discussion pieces (e.g., discussing what profiling is, how profiles are constructed, and when profiling is useful), despite the fact that the processes underlying offender profiling are still not well understood. Finally, although peer-reviewed articles exploring this topic have steadily increased, the statistical sophistication of these studies is sorely lacking, with most including no statistics or formal analyses of data. Suggestions for future research and recommendations to streamline efforts in this field are provided based on the results of this review.

Metacognition in Criminal Profiling

“…Conversely, it may be that in acknowledging these other profiling methods, they run the risk of "making them real," thereby validating any claims other authors make against their own paradigms. A short list of research suffering from this includes Dowden, Bennell, and Bloomfield (2007); Godwin (2002); Canter (2000); and Napier and Baker (2005). 3 3� More research needs to be conducted in the area of metacognition in criminal profiling.…”

Multidimensional Latent Classification of ‘Street Robbery’ Offences

“…For example, Goodwill et al found that in examining the association between crime scene behaviours and offender characteristics, both thematic and typological approaches were inferior to multivariate statistical approaches. Although somewhat limited in the past, the use of advanced multivariate statistics is now prominent in the offender profiling literature as evidenced by a marked increase in recent quantitative research articles (Dowden, Bennell, & Bloomfield, ).…”

Rape and sexual assault in investigative psychology: the contribution of sex offenders' research to offender profiling

“…A systematic review of the profi ling literature over the past 30 years shows that most papers have been published between 1996 and 2005 (Dowden, Bennell,were published during this 9-year period. Interestingly, rape was the second specifi c type of crime investigated, just behind homicide (Dowden, Bennell, & Bloomfi eld, 2007).…”