Addressing Professional Competency Problems in Clinical Psychology Trainees

Abstract

Objective: Clinical psychology trainees with problems of professional competence (PPC) continue to be a challenge for courses. Despite the rapid development of competency-based training models, the impact of this shift to the identification and management of professional competency problems is unclear. This project aims to describe how clinical psychology trainees with PPC are identified and managed within the Australian and New Zealand context. Method: An online survey was distributed through Australian and New Zealand universities offering clinical psychology training programmes. Questions addressed approaches to monitoring progress on placements, identification and management of trainees determined to be underperforming on placements, and the perceived usefulness of a range of strategies such as the use of standardised-rating tools. Results: Thirty one responses were received, representing 40 clinical psychology training courses in 22 institutions across Australia and New Zealand. In all cases, at least one trainee with a PPC had been detected in the previous 5 years, most commonly attributed to psychological, behavioural, and developmental issues. Respondents reported the use of a range of preventive and remedial strategies, including the use of psychometrically validated competency evaluation rating forms to assist in the grading of placements. Conclusion: Trainees with PPC occur on a fairly regular basis in clinical psychology training courses in Australian and New Zealand. While some processes involved in the identification and management of these students have been refined and systematised, some opportunities to facilitate early identification and remediation may yet need further enhancement.

Dear Mental Health Practitioners, Take Care of Yourselves: a Literature Review on Self-Care

“…Students need to be able to maintain their competence to engage as mental health practitioners and to meet the demands for self-care as required by professional associations. Although many universities in Australia, for example, recommend creating and modelling a culture of self-care for trainees (Perry et al 2017), unfortunately, self-care is not often formally taught or discussed within clinical training programs. In their review of 136 handbooks from clinical psychology doctoral programs, Bamonti et al (2014) found that only 8.4% of general psychology handbooks and 24.8% of clinical psychology handbooks included a reference to self-care, and that they primarily informed already impaired students about services available.…”

Evidence‐based practice within supervision during psychology practitioner training: A systematic review

“…Accurate and reliable measurement of early supervision and trainee competence is crucial to the objective evaluation of specific competencies and trainee performance (Gonsalvez & McLeod, 2008;Gonsalvez, Oades, & Freestone, 2002;Nicholson-Perry, Donovan, Knight, & Shires, 2017;Rodolfa et al, 2014;von Treuer & Reynolds, 2017). Further to this, comparison of supervisor and supervisee perceptions of supervision to determine which factors contribute to concordance and discordance in supervisory dyads regarding competency ratings and learning outcomes would be useful.…”

Changing the Quality of Teachers’ Written Tests by implementing an Authentic Assessment Teachers’ Training Program

“…A major challenge for professors is the ability to design valid assessment methods that really measure students' higher order thinking skills, which are described in undergraduate psychology programs' graduate profiles, and included in professional standards of different countries (Australian Psychological Society, 2013;Markle, 2017, Oliveri & Markle, 2017. Such assessments need to be ecologically valid, clearly reflecting the content and context of professional practice, while requiring the demonstration of complex thinking skills (Falchikov, 2004;Nicholson Perry, Donovan, Knight, & Shires, 2017).…”