Addressing data quality in Airbnb research

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to examine the primary supply data sources that have been used for research into the sharing economy, and the advantages and limitations of these sources in the literature. Design/methodology/approach To address the research aims, this study conducted a systematic literature review and content analysis of all relevant articles. Following the review, the methodological sections of the selected papers were examined to identify the characteristics and limitations of all data sources used in the papers. Findings This study revealed several limitations of the use of three major data sources, namely, web scraping with self-made bots, inside Airbnb and AirDNA, for sharing economy research. The review shows that the majority of the selected papers did not acknowledge any limitations, nor did they discuss the quality of the data sources. Research limitations/implications The findings of this paper can serve as guidelines for selecting appropriate data sources for research into the sharing economy and cautions researchers to address the limitations of the data sources used. Originality/value To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study that explores the advantages and limitations of data sources used in short-term rental market research.

Seize the favorable impression: how hosts should manage positive online reviews

“…Fourth, if new methods or data support become available in the future, scholars can first identify fake reviews when studying the effects of positive review response strategies. Finally, Airbnb does not disclose the sales performance of its listings (Prentice and Pawlicz, 2023); therefore, existing studies typically use review volume as a proxy for sales volume (Gao et al , 2022; Chen and Bi, 2022). Similarly, Xiaozhu does not provide sales data for listings.…”

Does prior trust work as a buffer? Examining the impact of perceived betrayal on customer responses to a double deviation

“…These tourism and hospitality companies have disrupted the business models of traditional hotels and the lodging industry (Han et al, 2023). Their success has been attributed to various causes, including the availability of customised choices, the democratisation of the hotel industry, the social interactions and local authenticity (Li et al, 2023;Prentice and Pawlicz, 2023).…”

“…Their success has been attributed to various causes, including the availability of customised choices, the democratisation of the hotel industry, the social interactions and local authenticity (Li et al. , 2023; Prentice and Pawlicz, 2023).…”