Adaptation of a clustered lumpy background model for task‐based image quality assessment in x‐ray phase‐contrast mammography

Abstract

Purpose: Since the introduction of clinical x-ray phase-contrast mammography (PCM), a technique that exploits refractive-index variations to create edge enhancement at tissue boundaries, a number of optimization studies employing physical image-quality metrics have been performed. Ideally, task-based assessment of PCM would have been conducted with human readers. These studies have been limited, however, in part due to the large parameter-space of PCM system configurations and the difficulty of employing expert readers for large-scale studies. It has been proposed that numerical observers can be used to approximate the statistical performance of human readers, thus enabling the study of task-based performance over a large parameter-space. Methods: Methods are presented for task-based image quality assessment of PCM images with a numerical observer, the most significant of which is an adapted lumpy background from the conventional mammography literature that accounts for the unique wavefield propagation physics of PCM image formation and will be used with a numerical observer to assess image quality. These methods are demonstrated by performing a PCM task-based image quality study using a numerical observer. This study employs a signal-known-exactly, background-known-statistically Bayesian ideal observer method to assess the detectability of a calcification object in PCM images when the anode spot size and calcification diameter are varied. Results: The first realistic model for the structured background in PCM images has been introduced. A numerical study demonstrating the use of this background model has compared PCM and conventional mammography detection of calcification objects. The study data confirm the strong PCM calcification detectability dependence on anode spot size. These data can be used to balance the trade-off between enhanced image quality and the potential for motion artifacts that comes with use of a reduced spot size and increased exposure time. Conclusions: A method has been presented for the incorporation of structured breast background data into task-based numerical observer assessment of PCM images. The method adapts conventional background simulation techniques to the wavefield propagation physics necessary for PCM imaging. This method is demonstrated with a simple detection task.

A feasibility study of X-ray phase-contrast mammographic tomography at the Imaging and Medical beamline of the Australian Synchrotron

“…Despite the intensive studies of the optimization of conventional (Johns & Yaffe, 1985) and phase-contrast (Zysk et al, 2012) mammographic imaging systems, the main known problem with this technique is that it produces a relatively high percentage of both false-positive and false-negative results (Pisano et al, 2005). A more recently introduced technique, digital tomosynthesis, generally delivers better results, mainly due to its three-dimensional (3D) imaging ability (multiple 2D slices through the breast) which reduces the effect of overlying breast tissue camouflaging focal breast masses (Ciatto et al, 2013).…”

Visual‐search observers for assessing tomographic x‐ray image quality

“…These methods are intended to evaluate imaging systems based on the performance of some clinically relevant task. Breast mass detection has been a common diagnostic assessment task, with observer studies related to phase-contrast imaging, 1,2 computed tomography (CT) 3 and digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) 4,5 having appeared over the past few years. Many of these x-ray imaging studies have employed statistical ideal observers, which provide a well-studied, tractable means of carrying out large-scale assessments in simulation.…”

Ideal‐observer detectability in photon‐counting differential phase‐contrast imaging using a linear‐systems approach

“…A simulation method and initial observer-model evaluation of anatomical noise in a mammography system for free-space propagation has recently been presented. 58…”