Acoustic Multinaturalism, the Value of Nature, and the Nature of Music in Ecomusicology

Abstract

This essay is a critique of the notions of nature and culture, as operationalized by the recently named field ecomusicology. While fields such as anthropology and history have questioned the idea of nature, ecomusicology, on the contrary, has explored its significance, producing an ecology of music and sound that reaffirms the term and, along with it, a multicultural account of diversity that takes the Western notion of culture as a viable concept for all peoples. This essay, rather, seeks to acknowledge a historical lineage of ethnomusicology and its relation to structuralism as fundamental for rethinking the ontologies of sound/music. This lineage is also fundamental for creating links with recent anthropological work on multinaturalism. Based on this work, the essay tentatively proposes the move toward acoustic multinaturalism as an alternative concept that is not bound to the creation of a new field but rather to rethinking the ontologies of the acoustic.

Haiti’s Drums and Trees: Facing Loss of the Sacred

“…And since "'becoming a bird' is the passage from life to death" (218), birds are not merely mediators but beings who embody the act of crossing between, from human to bird and back again, as in the myth of "The Boy Who Became a Muni Bird. " There appears to be no firmly defined boundary between species, or between human and nature, or between music and sound, as embedded in the Western imagination (see again Ochoa Gautier 2016).…”

Zooetnografías musicales multiespecie: cauces metodológicos de las músicas interespecíficas

“…6. Desde disciplinas como la etología y la etnomusicología, y desde campos de estudio y disciplinas emergentes como el poshumanismo, el denominado giro animal, los animal studies, la geografía animal, la etnografía multiespecie, la biocomunicación, la zoomusicología, la biocomunicación y la biosemiótica, entre otros (Buller 2014a;2014b;Chrulew 2014;De Waal 2001;Haraway 2007;Latour 1991;Mundy 2018;Murphy 1995;Ochoa Gautier 2016;Wolfe 2009).…”

Perspectiva acústica Ticuna (Magüta) e os perigos de se “ficar no silêncio”

“…Isso que chamei de "perspectiva acústica" foi desenvolvido recentemente de forma melhor elaborada pelos pesquisadores Matthias Lewy, Bernd Brabec de Mori e Ana Maria Ochoa Gautier. Desenvolvendo as consequências do perspectivismo no sentido de uma "ontologia do som", os autores lançam mão do conceito de "sonorismo ameríndio" (Lewy 2015), "perspectivismo sonoro" (Brabec de Mori 2012, 2015) ou "multinaturalismo acústico" (Gautier 2016). Com este complemento auditivo da perspectiva visual, teríamos a possibilidade de uma definição da perspectiva (sonora) de uma entidade para além de "sua fisicalidade e sua percepção visual" (Lewy 2015: 85).…”